Press Esc to close
Saturday 19 August 2017
News updated at 12:44 PM IST

Comed-K hopefuls get a reprieve

Bangalore, May 25, 2012, DHNS: 2:03 IST
The High Court on Friday annulled the first round of counselling for the postgraduate dental courses under the Comed-K, held on May 19, and ruled that the process be conducted afresh on May 29.

File photoThe ruling followed writ petitions filed by students who were barred from participating in the counselling for bringing “faulty” demand drafts (DDs).

Justice Ashok B Hinchigeri observed that the Comed-K should soften its stance vis-a-vis students who flouted the rules unknowingly.

Describing the Comed-K decision as “arbitrary, unreasonable, capricious and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution,” Juhi Moolchand Talesra, Pinal Mahendra Jain, Amrita Chakraborty and others moved the court on May 22, challenging its “rigidity” in implementing the rules.

“The students rushed to the nearest nationalised banks and bought fresh DDs, and immediately submitted them to the Comed-K officials, but they were given no leeway. The Comed-K did not publish the list of nationalised banks in the first place,” Ajay Patil, counsel for the students, submitted.

In defence, Comed-K counsel Madhusudan R Naik said one of the aggrieved students, Rinku Shankalesha Ramesh, in an email to the Comed-K at 10:04 am on May 19, admitted to bringing a DD from a non-nationalised bank.

Disputing the claim, the student said she had brought a demand draft from the Bank of Maharashtra, but was told that it was not a nationalised bank.

Patil rebutted Naik’s contention and said the DD number was not furnished by the Comed-K to buttress its claims. Justice Hinchigeri said she might have succumbed to anxiety and shot off the e-mail.

The court also sought to know whether some other students should have been disallowed for not getting the original bank counterfoils signed and sealed by the appropriate authorities.

Students can’t be blamed

The judge observed that the students could not be blamed if the bankers forgot to seal the counterfoils.

Observing that the system should honour performance of meritorious candidates, Justice Hinchigeri directed the Comed-K to redo the counselling and publish a list of all eligible candidates. “It is open to the respondents (Comed-K) or any college to examine eligibility of the petitioners.

The petition is allowed,” the judge said. The court also directed the Comed-K to publish the list of nationalised banks and set up a help desk and if desired, scrutinise the documents a day before the counselling.

Go to Top

Photo Gallery
A  file photo of  Infosys CEO Vishal Sikka...

A file photo of Infosys CEO Vishal Sikka...

Trainee recruits of Army undergo physical training at the Parachute Regiment Training...

Trainee recruits of Army undergo physical training at the Parachute Regiment Training...

A Chimpanzee looks on, at Alipore Zoological Garden in Kolkata...

A Chimpanzee looks on, at Alipore Zoological Garden in Kolkata...

A beautiful view of peacock on blooming tree branch at Bengre in Mangaluru...

A beautiful view of peacock on blooming tree branch at Bengre in Mangaluru...

People with their household belongings move to a relief camp from a flood-hit region...

People with their household belongings move to a relief camp from a flood-hit region...

Village women carry a Tri-colour as they row a boat across River Churni during Independence...

Village women carry a Tri-colour as they row a boat across River Churni during Independence...

An aerial view of a flood-hit area at Bal Bal in Betiah in West Chaparan, Bihar...

An aerial view of a flood-hit area at Bal Bal in Betiah in West Chaparan, Bihar...

A boy rows a makeshift raft as he transports a woman and a cooking gas cylinder through...

A boy rows a makeshift raft as he transports a woman and a cooking gas cylinder through...

A fruit vendor, holding an umbrella, waits for customers at a street in Kolkata on Thursday.

A fruit vendor, holding an umbrella, waits for customers at a street in Kolkata on Thursday.

Ranbir Kapoor, actor and co-owner Mumbai City FC meeting fans during the Indian Super League...

Ranbir Kapoor, actor and co-owner Mumbai City FC meeting fans during the Indian Super League...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.