Press Esc to close
Thursday 30 October 2014
News updated at 5:13 PM IST
Weather
Max: 0°C
Min : 0°C
In Bangalore
Sunny day

Gag on media

Sep 13, 2012

A fresh threat to the right to free speech and expression, which has been sanctified by the Constitution, has come from an unlikely place, the Supreme Court of India, which has in the past protected and promoted it as a basic entitlement of citizens. Its judgement empowering courts to ban reporting of hearings in cases where there is a perceived chance of interference in free and fair trial amounts to muzzling media freedom. It needs to be opposed like all other assaults on the functioning on the media, which are becoming frequent now. The court has propounded a  ‘constitutional principle’  which would allow aggrieved parties to seek postponement of the publication of hearings if they are seen to be prejudicial to the administration of justice. But this is disguising an unfair restriction as a constitutional doctrine, creating a devious device to undermine a basic right.

The court has desisted from laying down general guidelines on reporting of cases. That is welcome. But the right to seek a postponement of reporting and giving the courts the power to grant it on a case-by case basis would amount to imposition of the restrictive idea inherent in such guidelines. The court  considers it as a preventive rather than a prohibitive measure, and a neutralising technique to balance freedom of speech and fair trial and to protect the confidentiality of proceedings. But in effect many accused, especially those with resources, will become aggrieved defendants seeking a blackout of information in sensitive and important cases. Granting of their plea to hide information is not in public interest. Even if the press does not report there is a chance that the information can circulate in the cyber media.

Judicial proceedings have to be transparent so that decisions carry conviction with the people. It is a basic judicial idea that justice should not only be done but should also be seen to be done. A watchful and vigilant press is necessary for this. The media even now accepts and goes by reasonable restrictions on reporting of judicial proceedings. There are also instances of the courts conducting closed trials in rare cases. They also have the power of contempt to punish those who violate the rules of fair judicial reporting. There is no case to go beyond these and undermine important principles like the right to free speech and the right to know. The court should review its decision for the sake of basic rights and public interest.


Go to Top

Photo Gallery
Devotees offer prayers during Chhath festival celebrations at Galta Kund in Jaipur...

Devotees offer prayers during Chhath festival celebrations at Galta Kund in Jaipur...

Dipika Pallikal in action against Japan's Misaki Kobayashi in finals of JSW-PSA...

Dipika Pallikal in action against Japan's Misaki Kobayashi in finals of JSW-PSA...

Delhi Dynamos FC (orange) and North East United FC (white) players in action during...

Delhi Dynamos FC (orange) and North East United FC (white) players in action during...

President Pranab Mukherjee during the conference of directors of National Institutes...

President Pranab Mukherjee during the conference of directors of National Institutes...

Army personnel take position during a search operation of Lashkar-e-Taiba hideouts...

Army personnel take position during a search operation of Lashkar-e-Taiba hideouts...

Workers build the stage at the Wankhede stadium for the swearing in ceremony...

Workers build the stage at the Wankhede stadium for the swearing in ceremony...

Sri Lankan team during practice session before the match against India A...

Sri Lankan team during practice session before the match against India A...

Bollywood actor Shah Rukh Khan with filmmaker Farah Khan, actors Boman Irani...

Bollywood actor Shah Rukh Khan with filmmaker Farah Khan, actors Boman Irani...

Vehicles ply at Rajpath as fog covers it in New Delhi...

Vehicles ply at Rajpath as fog covers it in New Delhi...

A camel herder stands beside resting camels at the annual cattle fair in Pushkar...

A camel herder stands beside resting camels at the annual cattle fair in Pushkar...

Copyright 2014, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bangalore - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523