Press Esc to close
Wednesday 27 August 2014
News updated at 6:17 PM IST
Weather
Max: 28°C
Min : 20.2°C
In Bangalore
Generally cloudy

Bring judiciary under Lokpal: Justice N Santosh Hegde

New Delhi, Nov 28, 2012, (PTI) :

There is nothing wrong in bringing the Prime Minister under the jurisdiction of Lokpal as like others he is also a public servant, former Supreme Court Judge and erstwhile Karnataka Lokayukta N Santosh Hegde said today.

File Photo"What is wrong in the Lokpal having jurisdiction over the Prime Minister? Is the Prime Minister not a public servant? Aren't there cases of corruption against PMs in other countries? In Japan, you find every other year a Prime Minister is prosecuted.

(Former US President Richard) Nixon was prosecuted... What is so great about the PM?," he asked


Noting that the position of the Lokpal was akin to "giving a dog a bad name and kicking it", he said there have been allegations of corruption against Indian PMs in the past and added that only the President and Governors are excluded from being prosecuted and not the PM.

"We have had allegations of corruption against two former PMs - Bofors and the JMM bribery case. In a democracy, how can a person merely because he is holding an office be excluded from prosecution?

The Constitution excludes the prosecution of the President and the Governors in some cases...One can't apply the same principle on a man who passes executive orders on a daily basis," he told PTI.

Responding to a query as to how he expects Arvind Kejriwal's newly-launched 'Aam Aadmi Party' to perform, Hegde raised doubts about its success saying it was not an "easy job".

"My only apprehension is how far will a political party survive because of the very many demands of the political system, these days. It requires a huge amount of money to elect nearly 546 Members of Parliament from Kashmir to Kanyakumari. It is not going to be an easy job.

"It is a good thing in principle, but in reality, can it succeed?" he asked.

On being queried on Kejriwal's possible expose on corruption in judiciary, Hegde said, "Haven't we heard of malpractices in judiciary? We have had one Supreme Court judge against whom impeachment proceedings had started, but it was not completed. We had one Chief Justice against whom impeachment proceedings had been initiated- Justice Dinakaran- he resigned, so it came to an end.

"We had Soumitra Sen from Calcutta High Court. Impeachment process started against him (and then) stopped; didn't go anywhere. We have a charge sheet filed against Justice Nirmal Yadav of Punjab High Court. We have 34 judges of the Allahabad High Court, who are being investigated by the CBI.

"So, there is corruption there and therefore, he must be having some material against some judges," he said.

On being questioned if self regulation was the way for the judiciary to control corruption within its ranks, he said, "We have tried it and it has not succeeded.

We have tried it all these years...About the judiciary, everybody said that.. we will self-regulate, we will control, the superior court will look after the subordinate courts...nothing has happened," he said.

Hegde replied in the affirmative to a query on whether he is willing to have a Lokpal that has the authority to investigate and prosecute judges.

The very judge who is being investigated can go to the court- of which he may be a judge - and then question the investigation, he said.

"Who will investigate the judges? Somebody should be there. You want to have a separate investigating(sic)vigilance body of retired judges, then create it, that is okay, but it should not be out of the purview of investigation.

"That very judge, who is being investigated, can go to the same institution, court of which he is a judge and then question the investigation," he said.

Go to Top

Photo Gallery
Children dressed as Mother Teresa offer prayers on the occaision of her birthday in Bhopal ...

Children dressed as Mother Teresa offer prayers on the occaision of her birthday in Bhopal ...

J Sreenivasan, Vice President, Sales, TVS Motor Company, at the launch of TVS Scooty Zest 110 ...

J Sreenivasan, Vice President, Sales, TVS Motor Company, at the launch of TVS Scooty Zest 110 ...

Kaiser-e-Hind, a rare butterfly species in Ziro in Lower Subansiri district of Arunachal Pradesh ...

Kaiser-e-Hind, a rare butterfly species in Ziro in Lower Subansiri district of Arunachal Pradesh ...

An Army jawan distributes food to people of border villages who are affected by Pakistani shelling .

An Army jawan distributes food to people of border villages who are affected by Pakistani shelling .

Sheila Dikshit after a press conference following her resignation as Kerala Governor in New Delhi ..

Sheila Dikshit after a press conference following her resignation as Kerala Governor in New Delhi ..

BSF DG DK Pathak interacts with a person injured in border shelling in Jammu ...

BSF DG DK Pathak interacts with a person injured in border shelling in Jammu ...

Puducherry Chief Minister N Rangaswamy paying floral tributes to a statue of Mother Teresa ...

Puducherry Chief Minister N Rangaswamy paying floral tributes to a statue of Mother Teresa ...

An Army jawan during an encounter with militants, at Kalaro in Kupwara district  ...

An Army jawan during an encounter with militants, at Kalaro in Kupwara district ...

Britain's Deputy PM, Nick Clegg at Taj Mahal Hotel in Mumbai ...

Britain's Deputy PM, Nick Clegg at Taj Mahal Hotel in Mumbai ...

Rabbi Holtzberg speaks before the reopening ceremony of Nariman House in Mumbai ...

Rabbi Holtzberg speaks before the reopening ceremony of Nariman House in Mumbai ...

Copyright 2014, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bangalore - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523