Press Esc to close
Friday 22 May 2015
News updated at 1:52 PM IST
Weather
Max: 31.5°C
Min : 22.8°C
In Bengaluru
Sunny day

SC upholds appointment of Gujarat Lokayukta

Gandhinagar, Jan 2, 2013, DHNS :

Verdict a setback for Narendra Modi government

Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi at a press meet in Gandhinagar on Wednesday. PTI

The Supreme Court on Wednesday upheld the appointment of Justice R A Mehta, a retired High Court judge, as Gujarat Lokayukta, disregarding the state government’s opposition to his choice and objection to the selection process.

The apex court’s verdict came as a major setback to the Narendra Modi government which had challenged Governor Kamla Beniwal’s decision to go ahead with the appointment.

A bench of Justices B S Chauhan and F M I Kalifullah said the appointment was valid in law in view of the primacy of opinion by the High Court chief justice since he enjoyed an independent Constitutional status.

The governor, the High Court chief justice and the Leader of the Opposition in state Assembly had approved Justice Mehta’s choice to head the state anti-corruption watchdog.

However, the court in its judgment held that the governor could not appoint Lokayukta independently and went on to criticise Kamla Beniwal for completely bypassing the state government’s role in the appointment of the Lokayukta on August 25, 2011.

“The present governor has misjudged her role and has insisted that under the Act, the council of ministers has no role to play in the appointment of the Lokayukta, and that she could, therefore, fill it up in consultation with the chief justice of the Gujarat High Court and the Leader of Opposition. Such attitude is not in conformity, or in consonance with the democratic set-up of government envisaged in our Constitution,” the court said.

The apex court directed Justice Mehta to join immediately, while describing it as a “sorry state of affairs” where the post of Lokayukta had been lying vacant in Gujarat for more than nine years.

As far as the consultation process in appointment was concerned, the court noted that it was duly complete in August 2011 as per the Gujarat Lokayukta Act when three out of four statutory authorities—chief justice, governor and the Leader of Opposition—approved the name of Justice Mehta and that the chief justice also provided explanation to the chief minister, the fourth authority, on his objections.

But it added, “The appointment of the Lokayukta can be made by the governor, as the head of the state, only with the aid and advice of the council of ministers, and not independently as a statutory authority.”

Modi had shot off a letter in June 2011 to the High Court chief justice to re-consider Justice Mehta’s name in view of reports stating his association with certain NGOs and social activist groups, antagonists to the state government.

The chief justice had, however, termed Modi’s apprehensions as either irrelevant or not factually correct.

In its verdict, the court also disapproved the “harsh language” used by a third judge, against the chief minister who was a constitutional authority, like Modi demonstrated “deconstruction of democracy.”

The matter was referred to a third judge in the High Court following a split verdict in a division bench in the petition filed by the Gujarat government challenging the governor’s decision.


Go to Top

Photo Gallery
Textile Minister Subash Desai at the inauguration of Textile Park...

Textile Minister Subash Desai at the inauguration of Textile Park...

Mangoes on sale in the wholesale fruit market during summer season in Bhopal...

Mangoes on sale in the wholesale fruit market during summer season in Bhopal...

Actress Aishwarya Rai Bachchan walks during the 68th Annual Cannes Film Festival...

Actress Aishwarya Rai Bachchan walks during the 68th Annual Cannes Film Festival...

An Indian Air Force (IAF) Mi-17 V5 helicopter returns on Tuesday after dropping relief recent Nepal.

An Indian Air Force (IAF) Mi-17 V5 helicopter returns on Tuesday after dropping relief recent Nepal.

Mirage 2000 fighter aircraft of the Indian Air Force successfully lands on the Yamuna Expressway...

Mirage 2000 fighter aircraft of the Indian Air Force successfully lands on the Yamuna Expressway...

Girls paying floral tribute to former prime minister Rajiv Gandhi on his death anniversary...

Girls paying floral tribute to former prime minister Rajiv Gandhi on his death anniversary...

A Mahout sits on his elephant in Sabarmati river before giving bath to protect from heat...

A Mahout sits on his elephant in Sabarmati river before giving bath to protect from heat...

A Barn Swallow chicks inside a nest in Srinagar...

A Barn Swallow chicks inside a nest in Srinagar...

A cattle egret feeding its offsprings at nest on a tree in Guwahati on Thursday...

A cattle egret feeding its offsprings at nest on a tree in Guwahati on Thursday...

An Indian man takes bath under the tap of a water tanker on a hot day in Ahmadabad...

An Indian man takes bath under the tap of a water tanker on a hot day in Ahmadabad...

Copyright 2014, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523