Press Esc to close
Wednesday 26 July 2017
News updated at 10:05 AM IST

With KPSC's 'grace', they made it to plum posts

Bangalore, Subhash Chandra N S, July 14, 2013, DHNS: 1:51 IST

Some candidates were given marks in 'violation' of norms

Photo taken from the official website of Karnataka Public Service Commission.
RTI activists have brought to light violation of norms and nepotism galore in the recruitment of gazetted probationers by the Karnataka Public Service Commission (KPSC) since 1999.

Even as the issue is before the High Court and the CID for further investigation, more skeletons have tumbled out of the KPSC cupboard in connection with recruitments in 1998, 1999 and 2004. The RTI documents reveal how the KPSC has been ‘graceful’ to some candidates.

Documents available with the Deccan Herald show how some candidates had a cakewalk to the plum posts, while many meritorious candidates are still running from pillar to post in the hope of getting justice.

Three candidates, who had taken Law as optional subject in preliminary examination in 1999 (two candidates with register numbers 504314 and 504171), were given grace marks of 3.33 per question by the KPSC. In all, they got 75 marks and are now appointed as commercial tax officers and, one is a tahsildar. However, according to the KPSC recruitment guidelines formulated by the government, KPSC cannot allocate more than 2.5 marks as grace marks to a question in any subject during evaluation. The KPSC’s allocation of 3.33 marks itself is therefore illegal.

But, KPSC on June 9, 2000 passed a resolution in a meeting chaired by the then chairman S M Panchagatti in which members H C Neeravari, Dr H N Krishna, K Mukudappa, R Nagaraj, Mohammed Ali Khan, Lilian Xavier and secretary K Janardhan Rao were present.
This resolution stated that grace marks could be awarded since some of these questions were out of syllabus and hence they could allocate 3.33 marks per question.

However, the KPSC, in its reply to an RTI query by Ambasa Meharwadi on September 25, 2007, stated that it had no discretionary powers to change the rules and regulations made by the government in connection with recruitment. Hence, such allocation of marks was illegal.

In another instance, the KPSC was found to have favoured one candidate (register no 511351) by awarding him grace marks in preliminary examination and later allowed him to write the main examinations in 1999. Nine people approached the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal (KAT) after they failed in the preliminary exams.

The KAT allowed them to appear for the mains examination, subject to the result of the writ petition. Following this order, the KPSC chose to send the paper of just one candidate (register no 511351) to subject experts for revaluation and awarded him 12 grace marks in the preliminary exams. Once he wrote the main exams, that paper was retotalled and he was awarded 30 marks and later got another 152 marks in the interview.

But for another candidate M J Shivanna (register no 500200), who has sought a similar relief to appear for mains examination, the matter is still pending before the KAT. When another candidate sought more details about the grace marks awarded to him/her (register no 511351) through RTI, the KPSC stated that the file pertaining to the matter had been destroyed.

Go to Top

Photo Gallery
Newly sworn-in President Ram Nath Kovind inspecting a guard of honour in the forecourt...

Newly sworn-in President Ram Nath Kovind inspecting a guard of honour in the forecourt...

Tri-services guards leave after the swearing-in ceremony of the 14th President of India, at Vijay...

Tri-services guards leave after the swearing-in ceremony of the 14th President of India, at Vijay...

Indian Youth Congress activists hold placards during a silent protest against BJP and suspension...

Indian Youth Congress activists hold placards during a silent protest against BJP and suspension...

A view of Parliament after heavy rains in New Delhi on Tuesday....

A view of Parliament after heavy rains in New Delhi on Tuesday....

Fire brigade and NDRF personnel carrying out a search and rescue operation following a building...

Fire brigade and NDRF personnel carrying out a search and rescue operation following a building...

A Haj pilgrim displays her affection with her relative at Hajj House Bemina in Srinagar on Tuesday..

A Haj pilgrim displays her affection with her relative at Hajj House Bemina in Srinagar on Tuesday..

Members of the Kangleipak Students' Association (KSA) demand constitutional protection...

Members of the Kangleipak Students' Association (KSA) demand constitutional protection...

India's Ravichandran Ashwin tosses a ball during a training session ahead of the first test...

India's Ravichandran Ashwin tosses a ball during a training session ahead of the first test...

Actors Anil Kapoor and Arjun Kapoor promote their upcoming movie

Actors Anil Kapoor and Arjun Kapoor promote their upcoming movie "Mubarakan" in New Delhi...

A view of waterlogged George Town Police Station after heavy rains in Allahabad on Tuesday...

A view of waterlogged George Town Police Station after heavy rains in Allahabad on Tuesday...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.