Press Esc to close
Sunday 31 July 2016
News updated at 2:12 AM IST
Weather
Max: 23.2°C
Min : 19.8°C
In Bengaluru
Generally cloudy

Faux pas by Treasury Bench on a Food Security Bill clause

New Delhi, Aug 26, 2013, (PTI)

It was a faux pas by Treasury Benches members when they voted against a clause in the Food Security Bill in the Lok Sabha tonight, thinking it was a division on an amendment moved by the Leader of the Opposition Sushma Swaraj.

Swaraj moved an amendment to Chapter VIII of the Bill which states that in case the government is not able to provide the full quota of foodgrains it will pay cash for the worth of the remaining grains.

She said this cash will be misused by the male head of the family who will go straight to the liquor shop while the women and children will go hungry.

Following this, Speaker Meira Kumar put the Chapter for voting. UPA members thought this was a vote on the amendment moved by Swaraj and voted against.

There were 261 noes and 101 ayes of the total of 362 votes cast.

This led to a commotion in the House with the government realising its mistake while BJP members were on their feet in joy. Finance Minister P Chidambaram went to the Chair to explain. Congress MP Sandeep Dikshit and Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kamal Nath held discussions with Secretary General T K Vishwanathan.

Chidambaram and others asked the Treasury Benches to use slips to vote again.
Vishwanathan went upto Swaraj to discuss the matter.

Meanwhile, Swaraj and the BJP members said the votes cannot be recast as this is against the rules.

Finally, when Kamal Nath made a request to Swaraj and BJP Parliamentary Party Chief L K Advani, the party yielded.

"There has been some confusion and there was a technical fault," Nath said.

Yielding to the government's request, Swaraj said "normally this is not done. Slips are given for those whose votes are not cast. Since there is some confusion, the vote can be cast again," she said.

The clause was adopted when another round of voting took place.


Go to Top

Photo Gallery
A single horned rhino swims through flood waters in flood-hit Kaziranga National Park, in Assam...

A single horned rhino swims through flood waters in flood-hit Kaziranga National Park, in Assam...

Artist from Venkateshwara Natyamandira performing Bharatanatya on the occasion of KS&DL Centenary...

Artist from Venkateshwara Natyamandira performing Bharatanatya on the occasion of KS&DL Centenary...

Army personnel take position at the site of encounter where two Army soldiers and two militants ...

Army personnel take position at the site of encounter where two Army soldiers and two militants ...

An deserted and aerial view of Anand Rao circle fly over on Sheshadri road following the bandh...

An deserted and aerial view of Anand Rao circle fly over on Sheshadri road following the bandh...

A Dog is seen sitting in front of closed Shopping mall with Kannada flag displed during Karntaka...

A Dog is seen sitting in front of closed Shopping mall with Kannada flag displed during Karntaka...

An elephant moves through a waterlogged street after heavy rains in New Delhi on Friday...

An elephant moves through a waterlogged street after heavy rains in New Delhi on Friday...

People catching fish at flooded water due to heavy rain Madiwala Lake over flow...

People catching fish at flooded water due to heavy rain Madiwala Lake over flow...

Rain water flooded on the road at Anugraha Layout 2nd stage, Bilekahalli in Bengaluru...

Rain water flooded on the road at Anugraha Layout 2nd stage, Bilekahalli in Bengaluru...

Workers remove scaffolding from a replica of planet earth after repairs at Science City...

Workers remove scaffolding from a replica of planet earth after repairs at Science City...

Women unload rice grains from a boat to dry in the sunshine in flood affected village Murkata...

Women unload rice grains from a boat to dry in the sunshine in flood affected village Murkata...

Copyright 2014, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523