Press Esc to close
Thursday 29 January 2015
News updated at 5:47 PM IST
Weather
Max: 28°C
Min : 17°C
In Bengaluru
Sunny day

Personal details cannot be disclosed under RTI: Bombay HC

Mumbai, Sept 8, 2013 (PTI)
File image: For representational purpose

Under RTI, disclosure of personal information in respect of service record, income tax returns and assets of an individual is illegal unless it is necessary in larger public interest, the Bombay High Court has ruled.

Accordingly, Justice Vasanti Naik quashed an order of Nashik State Information Commissioner asking the information officer to supply information about personal assets of petitioner Subhash Khemnar to respondent Dilip Thorat.

"On hearing the petitioner and on perusal of the Act, it appears that the Chief Information Commissioner was not justified in directing Information Officer to supply personal information in respect of service record, income tax returns and assets of the petitioner unless he was satisfied that such disclosure was justified in larger public interest," said the judge in a recent order.

In the impugned order there is no finding with regard to the satisfaction of the Commissioner that the disclosure of the personal information in respect of the petitioner was justified in larger public interest, the judge noted.

Under section 8(1) J of the Act, there is no obligation on the Information Officer to give personal information, the disclosure of which has no relationship with any public activity or interest, or which would cause unwarranted invasion on the privacy of the individual unless the authority is satisfied that the disclosure of such information is justified in larger public interest, the Judge further said.

The petitioner had challenged the order passed by the Chief Information Officer on December 4 last year asking the information officer to supply personal information about him on a second appeal filed by the respondent.

Initially, the information officer did not supply the information and rejected the application filed by the respondent.

Thereafter he went in appeal before a higher authority but it was rejected. He then went in second appeal before the Chief Information Officer which was allowed. Being aggrieved, the petitioner moved the High Court.

According to the petitioner, the respondent was allegedly involved in extortion and the petitioner's brother-in-law had filed a complaint against the respondent for extortion. Also, the court had rejected the application filed by the respondent seeking anticipatory bail.


Go to Top

Photo Gallery
Prime Minister Narendra Modi awarding a winner cadet during the Prime Minister's NCC Rally, in...

Prime Minister Narendra Modi awarding a winner cadet during the Prime Minister's NCC Rally, in...

An illuminated Raisina Hills after the full dress rehearsal for the Beating Retreat ceremony in...

An illuminated Raisina Hills after the full dress rehearsal for the Beating Retreat ceremony in...

Ranchi Rays and Dabang Mumbai Hockey players in action during their HIL match in Ranchi on...

Ranchi Rays and Dabang Mumbai Hockey players in action during their HIL match in Ranchi on...

International body builder Ricardo Corriea at the BodyPower Expo 2015 in Bengaluru on Wednesday. PTI

International body builder Ricardo Corriea at the BodyPower Expo 2015 in Bengaluru on Wednesday. PTI

Kingfisher East Bengal (red & yellow) and Bengaluru FC (blue) in action during their I-League...

Kingfisher East Bengal (red & yellow) and Bengaluru FC (blue) in action during their I-League...

Kingfisher East Bengal (red & yellow) and Bengaluru FC (blue) in action during their I-League...

Kingfisher East Bengal (red & yellow) and Bengaluru FC (blue) in action during their I-League...

Supporters of AAP listen to convener Arvind Kejriwal during an election campaign in Shakurpur...

Supporters of AAP listen to convener Arvind Kejriwal during an election campaign in Shakurpur...

A MiG-27 of the Indian Air Force (IAF) crashes in Barmer district in Rajasthan on Tuesday...

A MiG-27 of the Indian Air Force (IAF) crashes in Barmer district in Rajasthan on Tuesday...

Goods trucks waits on Srinagar-Jammu National Highway during fresh snowfall...

Goods trucks waits on Srinagar-Jammu National Highway during fresh snowfall...

Indian and Chinese army officials standing near a rangoli, made on the occasion of Republic Day...

Indian and Chinese army officials standing near a rangoli, made on the occasion of Republic Day...

Copyright 2014, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523