Wednesday 16 April 2014
News updated at 1:12 PM IST
Weather
Max: 34°C
Min : 22.7°C
In Bangalore
Sunny day

Voodoo science?

'The IPCC has damaged its own reputation.'


The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) had no option but to express regret over its claim, made in a report it released in 2007, that the Himalayan glaciers would disappear by 2035, after it came to light recently that the claim was based on speculation. The retraction is fine but the controversy has done no credit to the IPCC, the premier UN agency which has an important role in climate change policy formulation. It has received the Nobel Prize for its work and advocacy. It is surprising that a body with such credentials would base its claim, by its own admission, on “poorly substantiated estimates” and forgo “clear and well-established standards” of evidence. It now turns out that a news story that appeared in the journal ‘New Scientist’, based on an interview with a researcher, was the source of the IPCC claim. The article had not been peer reviewed, nor its content verified against research findings.

The incident reflects poorly on the professionalism and scientific rigour of the IPCC and has done damage to its credibility. When India’s environment ministry had challenged the IPCC claim, the UN body’s chair, Rajendra Pachauri, had dubbed Indian glaciologists’ opinion as ‘voodoo science.’ The description unfortunately suits the IPCC’s claim. Doubts have now been raised about the IPCC’s claim on the rise of sea levels also. The IPCC has made good contribution to increasing global awareness on climate change issues. But when it makes alarmist and sensational claims, it is harming the cause it is campaigning for. Some months ago there were charges that scientists had cooked up data to make the impact of global warming look more serious than it is. Such controversies are used as weapons by those who deny or doubt the role of global warming in climate change. The threat to glaciers from global warming is real. Those who espouse and support corrective action for this should desist from cavalier and irresponsible ways.

The IPCC has also attracted adverse attention with some recent media reports questioning the business interests and financial dealings of its chief. Pachauri has denied any conflict of interest in his positions and the charge of any wrongdoing. It is for the UN body and its chief to ensure that it does not lower its moral and professional standing by any further lapses or errors. Its actions and processes should be guided by the best standards of scientific research and ethical conduct.


Go to Top

Photo Gallery
US actress Emma Stone poses for the media during the Germany premiere of the movie 'The Amazing ...

US actress Emma Stone poses for the media during the Germany premiere of the movie 'The Amazing ...

2013 Boston Marathon bombing survivor Erika Brannock, a pre-school teacher from the Baltimore ...

2013 Boston Marathon bombing survivor Erika Brannock, a pre-school teacher from the Baltimore ...

Family members and survivors of the 2013 Boston Marathon bombing walk down Boylston Street for a rem

Family members and survivors of the 2013 Boston Marathon bombing walk down Boylston Street for a rem

An injured passenger who was on a sinking ship, is rescued by South Korean maritime policemen ...

An injured passenger who was on a sinking ship, is rescued by South Korean maritime policemen ...

A passenger is rescued by South Korean maritime policemen from a sinking ship in the sea off ...

A passenger is rescued by South Korean maritime policemen from a sinking ship in the sea off ...

South Korea rescue helicopters fly over to rescue passengers from passenger ship Sewol ...

South Korea rescue helicopters fly over to rescue passengers from passenger ship Sewol ...

South Korean rescue helicopters fly over a South Korean passenger ship, trying to rescue ...

South Korean rescue helicopters fly over a South Korean passenger ship, trying to rescue ...

Britain's Kate, the Duchess of Cambridge meets with a girl during a walkabout in the Civic Square...

Britain's Kate, the Duchess of Cambridge meets with a girl during a walkabout in the Civic Square...

Britain's Prince William carries Prince George with his wife Kate, the Duchess of Cambridge ...

Britain's Prince William carries Prince George with his wife Kate, the Duchess of Cambridge ...

This multiple-exposure composite photo of the moon was made beginning at 1 a.m., CDT, Tuesday ...

This multiple-exposure composite photo of the moon was made beginning at 1 a.m., CDT, Tuesday ...

Copyright 2014, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bangalore - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523