Press Esc to close
Sunday 30 April 2017
News updated at 4:13 PM IST

Move to make CAG answerable to Parliament opposed

New Delhi: Oct 2, 2015, DHNS 1:43 IST
A proposal to make the Comptroller and Auditor General answerable to Parliament has run into a wall of opposition.

The proposal to make the CAG, an autonomous body, responsible to Parliament was made at the All India Conference of Public Accounts Committees of Parliament and state legislatures.

“The CAG is an independent institution and it should remain so. Making it answerable to Parliament would amount to dilution of its powers,” AICC spokesman Shobha Oza said.
BJP leader Nishikant Dubey had made a strong pitch for making the CAG responsible to Parliament by making relevant amendments to the 1971 law that governs the CAG.

“CAG should also be answerable to someone,” Dubey argued and pointed out that the government auditor was part of the legislature in the United Kingdom and Australia.
Senior Congress leader and PAC Chairman K V Thomas explained that the proposal was made by some chairpersons of the PACs of the state legislatures during the two-day meeting in September.

Parliament sources cited the example of the Election Commission, also a Constitutional authority, which was made into a three-member body after the controversial tenure of the then Chief Election Commissioner T N Seshan. “This is just a proposal and it is yet to be discussed by the PAC,” Thomas said.

BJD leader and Lok Sabha member Bhratruhari Mahtab, who is also member of the Public Accounts Committee, also strongly favoured retaining the existing nature of the CAG. “The CAG is an independent body and it should continue to function independently,” Mahtab told Deccan Herald.

He said the PAC acts as a quasi-judicial body whenever there are differences of opinion between the Executive and the government auditor, the decision of the Public Accounts Committee is final. “Once we make CAG accountable to Parliament, you cannot have the PAC functioning judiciously,” said Mahtab, who is the leader of the BJD in the Lok Sabha.
JD(U) president Sharad Yadav also opposed any changes to the C&AG. “Institutions are built over a period of time. It would be wrong to take away the independence or autonomy of the C&AG,” he said.

Shiv Sena leader Anand Adsul also opposed the proposal. “If the CAG has to function efficiently, it has to be independent,” said Adsul, who represents Amravati constituency in the Lok Sabha.

“I have been a member of the PAC for 7-8 years and I have never felt that the C&AG should be made responsible to Parliament,” said Adsul, who also served as Union Minister during Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s tenure as prime minister.

A three-member sub-committee of the PAC, chaired by BJP leader Nishikant Dubey, will examine the 20-odd recommendations made by the conference, including making CAG accountable to Parliament. The report of the sub-committee will be discussed by the full PAC which would give the final shape to the recommendations.

Go to Top

Photo Gallery
My Take: Can you count colours? Photo by Nalini R Magal from Hassan...

My Take: Can you count colours? Photo by Nalini R Magal from Hassan...

My Take: Happiness as a warm puppy. Photo by Varsha Chalageri from Dharwad...

My Take: Happiness as a warm puppy. Photo by Varsha Chalageri from Dharwad...

My Take: Pretty posers. Photo by Siddhi Doddanavar, from Belgaum...

My Take: Pretty posers. Photo by Siddhi Doddanavar, from Belgaum...

My Take: You mean, I wont grow up to be a tiger? Photo by Praveenkumar P K from Dharwad

My Take: You mean, I wont grow up to be a tiger? Photo by Praveenkumar P K from Dharwad

The good side vs the bad side. Photo by Gayatri Venkatesh from Bengaluru...

The good side vs the bad side. Photo by Gayatri Venkatesh from Bengaluru...

Border Security Force (BSF) personals handing over a 15 years old Pakistani national Razak...

Border Security Force (BSF) personals handing over a 15 years old Pakistani national Razak...

Basaveshwara statue is decorated on the occasion of Basava Jayanthi and Akshaya Tritiya....

Basaveshwara statue is decorated on the occasion of Basava Jayanthi and Akshaya Tritiya....

A Japanese Hitoshi Takahashi biker performs stunt during Yamaha FMX stunt show in Kochi, Kerala...

A Japanese Hitoshi Takahashi biker performs stunt during Yamaha FMX stunt show in Kochi, Kerala...

People use umbrella to protect from rain at at MG Road and Kasturba Road junction in Bengaluru...

People use umbrella to protect from rain at at MG Road and Kasturba Road junction in Bengaluru...

A lion beats the heat by relaxing under a tree at Dr Shivaram Karnath Biological Park...

A lion beats the heat by relaxing under a tree at Dr Shivaram Karnath Biological Park...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.