You are here: Home » International » India wants 'credible answers' from Australia over attacks
India wants 'credible answers' from Australia over attacks
Melbourne, Feb 10 (PTI):
Concerned over a series of attacks on its nationals, India today sought ''credible answers'' from Australia so that it could send a clear message to worried parents of more than 120,000 Indian students here.
"It is important to understand that there is anger and frustration in India over what is happening (in Australia)," Indian High Commissioner Sujatha Singh said in an article published in the Age newspaper here. She said that the anxious parents of over 120,000 Indian students in Australia are asking for clear answers to certain questions: "Are our children safe in Australia? Why does it seem that only, or mainly, Indians are the victims? Are the assailants being caught? Are they being punished? Is the situation becoming better or worse?" "I cannot overstate the importance of keeping the human element in the forefront in providing credible answers to these questions and sending a clear message to parents far away in India, worrying about their children in Australia," she wrote ahead of her visit to India to brief the government over the steps taken by Australia to address its concerns. Over 100 cases of attacks on Indians have been reported since the last year in Australia, mostly in Victoria, and the issue has been taken up by top representatives of the Indian government with their Australian counterparts.
"The assaults on Indian students and members of the larger Indian community in Australia over the past few months have puzzled us all... The fundamental issue is the growing number of attacks, which seem to be disproportionately affecting Indians, especially in and around Melbourne," she said. "We are told that one of the reasons our students are being attacked in Melbourne is that they take public transport late at night. In this case, it should then apply to Indian students all across Australia," she said, adding that the students in the other cities, however, do not seem to be facing these incidents on the same scale. "I have been called to India for consultations this week, in the run-up to the upcoming Parliament session, beginning on February 22," Singh said. She said India recognises several measures taken by Australia to address the various issues, many of them complex and interrelated. But said, "it is important to go beyond rhetoric. We have to make the situation better. It is necessary to see the results on the ground." Australia yesterday acknowledged that some of the recent violence against Indians had clearly been "racially motivated" and vowed to "punish the culprits with the full force of law". Foreign Minister Stephen Smith told the Parliament yesterday that "if any of these attacks have been racist in nature -- and it seems clear that some of them have -- they will be punished with the full force of law".
First, racist attacks are deplorable, anywhere. Any attack is deplorable, anywhere. My sincere apologies to those who have suffered in Australia.
As regards crime rates. There have been 100 assaults on Indian students. These number c. 100,000. The rate of assault in the general population is approximately 850 in 100,000. So statistically, Indian students are safer than me.
As to "your Aussie mates dont seem to be even attempting to catch the bashers", please refer to http://www.deccanherald.com/content/48400/two-arrested-over-attack-indian.html in this newspaper (the article outlines arrests that took place almost immediately) and http://news.ino.com/headlines/?newsid=12720100067 (of eighteen high profile cases of deaths and serious injury to Indians, 13 were solved, 3 unsolved and two proved to be accidents/suicides).
As regards India Pakistan relations, even when living in India I did not consider it my place to comment. Hope you can work it out.
POE
Look at the Indian Hypocricy. India itself hasnt punished kasab for 26/11 but wants Pakistan to speed up trial. Afzal hanging is still not done.
Maha Govt couldnt prevent attacks in Mumbai of fellow Indians but wants security for Indians in Australia. Someone needs to rebuke Indian Politicians to stop being hypocrites.
Hey Ram!! You got the message. Thats exactly what India is saying. Catch the students bashers and put them on trial. Show that you are keen on doing justice-dont worry even if takes time. We are asking Pakistan to speed up trial so also we are asking Australia. Where is hypocracy here? If you call consistency as hypocracy, mate the shoe is on the wrong foot. Your Aussie mates dont seem to be even attempting to catch the bashers. Again you got your foot in the mouth when you said Shivsena is attacking fellow Indians. Ms Sujatha Singh is not talking about Australians attacking themselves. We know that NSW doesnt allow Victorians play at intl. level despite the latter being 10 better (yes, Shane was, so were Bill Lawry, Graham Yallop et al.). But thats upto Aust. selectors. Your Maharashtra analogy is an internal matter of India. There are dirty linens all over the world. You wash it in Murray and we will do in our nallahs.
