Press Esc to close
Thursday 17 August 2017
News updated at 2:53 AM IST

Mining: SC refuses to keep alive Dharam's plea

DH News Service, New Delhi, Aug 10 2017, 2:30 IST

The Supreme Court on Wednesday ref­u­s­ed to keep alive a plea that was made by former Karnataka Chief Minister N Dharam Singh against a High Court of Karnataka order for recovery of over Rs 23 crore from him for the losses caused to exchequer in transportation of illegally-extracted iron ores.

“The petitioner is stated to be no more. The case does not survive,” a bench of Justices Ranjan Gogoi and Navin Sinha said and closed the special leave petition filed by the late Congress leader. Singh (80) passed away on July 27. Senior advocate Mahalakshmi Pavani, appearing for Singh, submitted that the matter should be decided by the apex court as his legal heirs could be affected by the high court’s decision of 2012.

The bench, however, told the counsel, “That is something which we cannot decide at the moment. You can move the high court as the petitioner had approached us against an interim order. In the event of high court’s order against you, the matter can be mentioned here in case the legal heirs are affected.”

The court also declined a plea by Pavani to keep alive the question of law if immunity granted to Governor is open to judicial review when he exercises his power as competent authority under the Karnataka Lokayukta Act in granting sanction of prosecution of a public servant.

Bengaluru resident
D Natesh had filed a PIL in the high court, claiming that Singh had ignored the advice given by then secretary of the Mines and Geology department. But, the then Governor Rameshwar Thakur on June 23, 2009 had held that no action was required against Singh as he had not made pecuniary gains.

The Lokayukta, in its first report on mining, had held Singh guilty of misconduct and responsible for causing losses to the exchequer by permitting transportation of 2.38 lakh tonnes of iron ore, mined and stored illegally by landowners in five districts during his tenure as chief minister.

The Governor, acting as competent authority in case of complaints against the then chief minister, had in June 2009 rejected the recommendation of the Lokayukta, which was not open to judicial review, Singh had claimed.


Go to Top

Photo Gallery
A street memorial is lit during a candlelight vigil for Elvis Presley in front of Graceland...

A street memorial is lit during a candlelight vigil for Elvis Presley in front of Graceland...

Festival goers participate in a color party at the 25th Sziget (Island) Festival...

Festival goers participate in a color party at the 25th Sziget (Island) Festival...

Manchester City's Phil Foden, right, duels for the ball during the Costa Brava trophy friendly...

Manchester City's Phil Foden, right, duels for the ball during the Costa Brava trophy friendly...

A zoo keeper holding the 2.5-month old Borneo Orangutan baby 'Hujan' in her arms in Krefeld...

A zoo keeper holding the 2.5-month old Borneo Orangutan baby 'Hujan' in her arms in Krefeld...

Border Security Force (BSF) personnel wave the Tricolor and perform Bhangra as they...

Border Security Force (BSF) personnel wave the Tricolor and perform Bhangra as they...

Congress Vice President Rahul Gandhi, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah...

Congress Vice President Rahul Gandhi, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah...

A model walks the ramp during Lakme Fashion Week displaying Ritu Kumar's collection in Mumbai...

A model walks the ramp during Lakme Fashion Week displaying Ritu Kumar's collection in Mumbai...

: Flood-affected villagers commute to safer places using a boat at Morigaon district in Assam...

: Flood-affected villagers commute to safer places using a boat at Morigaon district in Assam...

Monkeys playing with a water pipe near Vijay Chowk in New Delhi on Wednesday

Monkeys playing with a water pipe near Vijay Chowk in New Delhi on Wednesday

Flamingoes preening in their enclosure at the zoo in Duisburg, Germany, 16 August 2017.

Flamingoes preening in their enclosure at the zoo in Duisburg, Germany, 16 August 2017.

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.