Press Esc to close

O Jerusalem! For Trump, everything is local politics

Mark Landler, International New York Times, Dec 8 2017, 0:21 IST
A Jewish man blows a shofar with the Dome of the Rock in the distance, in Jerusalem, Dec. 6, 2017.President Trump plans to name Jerusalem as the capital of Israel on Wednesday, upending nearly seven decades of American foreign policy. (Uriel Sinai/The New York Times)

A Jewish man blows a shofar with the Dome of the Rock in the distance, in Jerusalem, Dec. 6, 2017.President Trump plans to name Jerusalem as the capital of Israel on Wednesday, upending nearly seven decades of American foreign policy. (Uriel Sinai/The New York Times)

Ten days before Donald Trump took office, Sheldon Adelson went to Trump Tower for a private meeting. Afterward, Adelson, the casino billionaire and Republican donor, called an old friend, Morton A Klein, to report that Trump told him that moving the US Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem would be a major priority.

"He was very excited, as was I," said Klein, the president of the Zionist Organization of America, a hard-line pro-Israel group. "This is something that's in his heart and soul."

The two men had to wait nearly a year, but on Wednesday, Trump stood beneath a portrait of George Washington to announce that he was formally recognising Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and setting in motion a plan to move the embassy to the fiercely contested Holy City.

"While previous presidents have made this a major campaign promise," he said, "they failed to deliver. Today, I am delivering."

For Trump, the status of Jerusalem was always less a diplomatic dilemma than a political imperative. Faced with disappointing evangelical and pro-Israel backers like Adelson, or alarming allies and Arab leaders while jeopardising his own peace initiative, the president sided with his key supporters.

In doing so, Trump invited opprobrium from foreign leaders, who said the move was reckless and self-defeating. He also acted against the counsel of Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and Defence Secretary Jim Mattis, who worried about anti-American blowback, not least to diplomats and troops serving overseas.

Trump conceded the provocative nature of his decision. But as he has before, whether in pulling the United States from the Paris climate accord or disavowing the Iran nuclear deal, the president on Wednesday seemed to relish playing a familiar role: the political insurgent, defying foreign policy orthodoxy on behalf of the people who elected him.

"People are waking up to the fact that the president doesn't see greys and doesn't like pastels," said Christopher Ruddy, a conservative news media executive and friend of Trump's. "He is very proud that he's fulfilled so many campaign promises, and the embassy decision is another notch on his belt."

Trump's handling of the embassy question was not unlike his handling of the nuclear deal with Iran, which he reluctantly certified the first time before disavowing it the second time the issue came up.

Under a 1995 law, the president is required to move the embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem unless citing national security concerns, he signs a waiver, which has to be renewed every six months. The first time he faced that decision, in June, Trump grudgingly signed it.

His son-in-law, Jared Kushner, who is leading Trump's peace initiative, argued at the time that to move the embassy then might strangle the effort before the administration had established relationships in the region.

Adelson and other pro-Israel backers were deeply frustrated. He pressed Trump on the issue at a private dinner in October at the White House that included his wife, Miriam, and Kushner. Adelson also vented to Stephen Bannon,
then the president's chief strategist, who argued internally for moving the embassy in June.

The Adelsons have long been leading donors to pro-Israel groups and causes, and have forged a close relationship with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. They have used their casino fortune to push the Republican Party and its politicians to embrace that line.

Early in Trump's campaign for the Republican presidential nomination, he privately courted the Adelsons, seeking a meeting and asking for financial support, even as he publicly declared that he did not need or want support from major donors.

In March 2016, Trump sought to burnish his credentials as a friend of Israel, telling the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, the most powerful pro-Israel lobbying group, "We will move the American Embassy to the eternal capital of the Jewish people, Jerusalem."

The Adelsons were persuaded and donated $20 million to a political action committee that supported Trump's campaign, and another $1.5 million to the committee that organised the Republican convention. Since Trump took office, Adelson has communicated with him regularly, talking by phone and visiting the White House, and has used his access to push the relocation of the embassy. But he was not the only influential advocate of the move.

Representatives of evangelical Christian groups similarly pressed the issue with Trump during the campaign, making it clear that moving the embassy was a major priority.

"In the meetings I was in, it was clearly communicated that evangelicals and Bible-believing Christians see a special relationship with Israel," said Tony Perkins, the president of the Family Research Council.

When the six-month clock expired again this month, Trump was determined to leave himself more options. On November 27, he walked into a meeting of the principals' committee of the National Security Council, as the officials were debating what to do about the embassy. His message, according to officials, was that he wanted more creative solutions.

A calculated call

Trump's advisers offered him two alternatives: sign the waiver again, or sign it but recognise Jerusalem as the capital and set in motion a plan to move the embassy. Trump mulled the decision for several days, officials said, calling foreign leaders and lawmakers on Capitol Hill. And on Wednesday he announced he was taking the more aggressive approach, again signing the waiver but making it clear he would proceed with a move.

His decision was supported by both Kushner and the president's special envoy, Jason D Greenblatt, who had concluded that shaking up the status quo could actually help rather than hurt their peace efforts. While they say they recognised that it would cause an immediate uproar - including potentially driving the Palestinians away from negotiations for some time - they believed the process was resilient enough to withstand the shock.

Amid all the warnings about violence, White House officials see a number of potential benefits to the move. Recognising Jerusalem, officials said, could soothe the right flank of Netanyahu's coalition government, stabilising the political situation there.

Also, the Saudi royal family has sharply criticised Trump's decision, which officials said could help the credibility of Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman among his fellow Arabs. That could mitigate perceptions that the crown prince has grown too cosy with Kushner, with whom he has cultivated a close relationship.

In his speech, Trump did not dwell on how his decision might play out in the region. Rather, he cast it as a bold break with decades of failed policy on Jerusalem, which he said brought us "no closer to a lasting peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians."

"It would be folly to assume that repeating the exact same formula would now produce a different or better result," Trump said.

Though he did not mention it, Trump signed the same waiver as his predecessors, Bill Clinton, George W Bush and Barack Obama, to keep the embassy in Tel Aviv for now. White House officials said that was unavoidable because it would take several years to move embassy employees to a new building in Jerusalem.

For Trump, the political benefits clearly outweigh the costs. The Republican Jewish Committee bought a full-page ad in NYT that is to be published on Thursday, depicting Trump praying at the Western Wall. "President Trump," the slogan said, "You Promised. You Delivered."

Go to Top

More from this section
Most trending stories
Photo Gallery
Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses the media on the first day of the winter session...

Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses the media on the first day of the winter session...

Outgoing Congress president Sonia Gandhi, former prime minister Manmohan Singh, Congress...

Outgoing Congress president Sonia Gandhi, former prime minister Manmohan Singh, Congress...

INLD MP Dushyant Chautala arrives by a tractor to attend the winter session of Parliament...

INLD MP Dushyant Chautala arrives by a tractor to attend the winter session of Parliament...

Social activist Anna Hazare while addressing a press conference at the Guwahati Press club, in...

Social activist Anna Hazare while addressing a press conference at the Guwahati Press club, in...

Members of Anganwadi workers hold a protest against Uttar Pradesh Government in support of their...

Members of Anganwadi workers hold a protest against Uttar Pradesh Government in support of their...

Election observers inspecting the EVM (Electronic Voting Machines) at a distribution centre...

Election observers inspecting the EVM (Electronic Voting Machines) at a distribution centre...

A vegetable vendor sits between the wheels of a parked truck, in a street market in Kolkata on...

A vegetable vendor sits between the wheels of a parked truck, in a street market in Kolkata on...

Army jawans near a helicopter parked at Kolkata maidan during foggy Friday morning. Historic Victori

Army jawans near a helicopter parked at Kolkata maidan during foggy Friday morning. Historic Victori

A fisherman casting his net at Dal Lake during a cold winter morning, in Srinagar on...

A fisherman casting his net at Dal Lake during a cold winter morning, in Srinagar on...

Muslims pray on the steps of a mosque during a demonstration against the...

Muslims pray on the steps of a mosque during a demonstration against the...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.