Press Esc to close

Four senior most SC judges singed by handling of MoP

Ashish Tripathi, DH News Service, New Delhi, Jan 13 2018, 17:11 IST
Four senior superme court judges, apparently singed by the handling of the Memorandum of Procedure by CJI Dipak Misra, decided to air their grievances in a press conference.

Four senior superme court judges, apparently singed by the handling of the Memorandum of Procedure by CJI Dipak Misra, decided to air their grievances in a press conference.

Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra's handling of the issue pertaining to Memorandum of Procedure -- has apparently singed the four senior-most judges of the Supreme Court to lodge their protest in public.

Besides objecting to the allocation of cases to particular benches, the four judges led by Justice J Chelameswar also questioned a two-judge bench's decision to entertain a petition filed by R P Luthra on the issue on October 27, last. Though a three-judge bench presided over by the CJI had subsequently on November 8 overturned the judicial order, the four judges, however, went on to ventilate their grievances in public on Friday.

The MoP has remained pending since Constitution bench decision on December 16, 2016, in view of the tug-of-war between the judiciary and the Union government over certain clauses like the rejection of candidates on national security, widening zone of consultation, complaint disposal mechanism etc.

In their letter to the CJI about two months, they said that there was no occasion for the bench (of Justices Adarsh K Goel and U U Lalit) to make an observation with regard to the finalisation of the MoP or that the issue cannot linger on for an indefinite period.

The four judges, including Justices Ranjan Gogoi, Madan B Lokur and Kurian Joseph, objected to the judicial order passed by the two-judge bench wherein a response was sought from Attorney General.

When the MoP was the subject matter of a decision of a Constitution Bench of this court, in Supreme Court Advocates-on-record Association and Anr Vs Union of India (2016), it is difficult to understand as to how any other bench could have dealt with the matter, they said.

They pointed out after the Constitution Bench's decision in NJAC, detailed discussions were held by the Collegium of five judges and the MoP was finalised and sent by the then Chief Justice of India to the government in March 2017.

"The Government of India has not responded to the communication and in view of this silence, it must be taken that the MoP as finalised by the Collegium has been accepted by the Government," the letter stated.

They have demanded the CJI to "rectify the situation and take appropriate remedial measures after a full discussion with the other members of the collegium and at a later stage, if required, with other Hon'ble judges of this court."

Interestingly, the CJI-led bench had on November 8 scuttled the move by a two-judge bench to examine "indefinite delay" in finalisation of the MoP for the appointment of judges in the apex court and the High Courts. "There was no necessity to pass any interim order in view of the Constitution bench decision. These are not matters to be taken on the judicial side. That's all," the bench, also comprising Justices A K Sikri and Amitava Roy had said.

Go to Top

More from this section
Most trending stories
Photo Gallery
Miss World 2017 Manushi Chhillar and actor Rekha pose for a picture...

Miss World 2017 Manushi Chhillar and actor Rekha pose for a picture...

Actor Sunny Leone gives her measurement for her wax statue to be displayed at Madame Tussauds...

Actor Sunny Leone gives her measurement for her wax statue to be displayed at Madame Tussauds...

A woman dries red chillies at a field in a village near Jodhpur on Thursday....

A woman dries red chillies at a field in a village near Jodhpur on Thursday....

Pope Francis holds a cross that reads in Spanish

Pope Francis holds a cross that reads in Spanish "I give you my peace" upon arrival...

A villager displays a mortar shell allegedly fired on a residential area from the Pakistan...

A villager displays a mortar shell allegedly fired on a residential area from the Pakistan...

A contingent of Territorial Army wait during the Republic Day parade rehearsal at Rajpath...

A contingent of Territorial Army wait during the Republic Day parade rehearsal at Rajpath...

'Boyevaya Machine Pekhoty' tanks seen at Vijay Chowk during the Republic Day parade rehearsal...

'Boyevaya Machine Pekhoty' tanks seen at Vijay Chowk during the Republic Day parade rehearsal...

Artists paint an idol of Goddess Saraswati at a workshop in Amritsar on Thursday...

Artists paint an idol of Goddess Saraswati at a workshop in Amritsar on Thursday...

Cranes lift a Boeing 737-800 of Turkey's Pegasus Airlines in Trabzon, Turkey...

Cranes lift a Boeing 737-800 of Turkey's Pegasus Airlines in Trabzon, Turkey...

Tableaux artists rehearse for the upcoming Republic Day parade at Rajpath in New Delhi...

Tableaux artists rehearse for the upcoming Republic Day parade at Rajpath in New Delhi...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.