Press Esc to close
Sunday 20 August 2017
News updated at 3:00 AM IST

DNA fingerprinting not exactly reliable in forensics

Last updated: 12 August, 2010
London, Aug 12 (IANS): 12:55 IST

DNA evidence is not exactly reliable in criminal investigation as interpretation of samples can be highly subjective and prone to error, says a new study.

The incredibly small amount of DNA in samples and pressure to gain a conviction can lead to bias, according to an investigation by New Scientist, reports the Daily Mail.

The magazine sent a sample of DNA from a real crime scene to 17 experienced analysts in a US lab. The experts' differing results cast doubts over the technique's reliability.

The sample, from a gang rape, had already been used to convict a man but only one of the 17 scientists came to the same conclusion.

Itiel Dror, a University College London scientist, who helped set up the investigation, said: "It is time DNA analysts accept that under certain conditions, subjectivity may affect their work.'

Christine Funk, a defence lawyer in the US, said: "The difference between prison and freedom rests in the hands of the scientist assigned the case."

The chances of two people having the same DNA fingerprint are between 800,000 and one billion to one. But there are concerns that increasing reliance on tiny samples of blood and saliva, often from more than one person, leaves interpretation open to the scientist's judgment.

"Profiling is generally seen as infallible and it is always able to get its man. But DNA profiling is far from perfect," the New Scientist added.

Kay Francis of the Forensic Science Service, which handles bulk of the police's forensics work, said: "Britain has led the world in terms of breakthroughs in forensic science. North America is quite a bit behind in that aspect."

Go to Top

Photo Gallery
Bollywood actor Vidyut Jamwal showcases a creation by designer Kazingmei during Lakme Fashion...

Bollywood actor Vidyut Jamwal showcases a creation by designer Kazingmei during Lakme Fashion...

Farmers takes part in oxen race of Kalapoottu in Pullaloor in Kozhikode...

Farmers takes part in oxen race of Kalapoottu in Pullaloor in Kozhikode...

Youngsters sit inside Humes pipes at a city street in Kolkata...

Youngsters sit inside Humes pipes at a city street in Kolkata...

Devotees performs 'Deodhani', a traditional folk dance from the Indian state of Assam...

Devotees performs 'Deodhani', a traditional folk dance from the Indian state of Assam...

Children stand waist-deep in flood water as they wait for rescue workers in Katihar...

Children stand waist-deep in flood water as they wait for rescue workers in Katihar...

A  file photo of  Infosys CEO Vishal Sikka...

A file photo of Infosys CEO Vishal Sikka...

Trainee recruits of Army undergo physical training at the Parachute Regiment Training...

Trainee recruits of Army undergo physical training at the Parachute Regiment Training...

A Chimpanzee looks on, at Alipore Zoological Garden in Kolkata...

A Chimpanzee looks on, at Alipore Zoological Garden in Kolkata...

A beautiful view of peacock on blooming tree branch at Bengre in Mangaluru...

A beautiful view of peacock on blooming tree branch at Bengre in Mangaluru...

People with their household belongings move to a relief camp from a flood-hit region...

People with their household belongings move to a relief camp from a flood-hit region...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.