Image for representation showing graphs.
Credit: iStock Photo
Quarterly earnings reports are more than just financial updates, they reflect a company’s commitment to transparency and accountability. Investors depend on these reports to track performance and make informed decisions. Sometimes, when performance is weak or a business segment underperforms, companies may attempt to ‘dress up’ the numbers — a practice known as window dressing — to conceal the negatives and mislead stakeholders.
That’s why it’s essential to know how to analyse quarterly results properly and spot red flags in a timely manner. Identifying these warning signs can help you avoid risky companies and focus on those that are genuinely trustworthy.
Let’s understand this in detail.
To analyse like a pro:
Don’t just look at the numbers
Headline figures can be misleading when viewed in isolation. A 20% revenue jump might seem impressive, but the real question is — was it already anticipated by the market? Was it driven by genuine volume growth or just a price hike?
To properly assess performance, benchmark the results against analyst expectations, past management guidance, and peer company performance within the same industry.
Listen to the management
Don’t stop at profit and loss statements, pay close attention to management commentary during earnings calls. What the company says about its capex plans, demand outlook, or hiring trends can offer valuable insights. Even subtle phrases like ‘pricing pressure’ or ‘inventory challenges’ can hint at future concerns.
The tone, confidence, and clarity of management communication often say more than the numbers themselves.
Margins tell the real story
While revenue and profit can sometimes be polished, margins tend to reveal the truth. Focus on:
Gross margin: Indicates pricing power vs input costs
EBITDA margin: Reflects operational efficiency
Net margin: Shows the final profitability after interest, tax, and other expenses
Compare these margins year-on-year and quarter-on-quarter while keeping in mind factors like raw material costs, wage expenses, and finance charges.
Watch out for any item that shows an unusual spike or dip compared to past trends.
Cash flow vs profit
Always verify whether reported profits are supported by actual cash flow. High net profit with weak or negative operating cash flow isn’t sustainable, it may indicate delayed payments, rising receivables, or aggressive revenue booking.
Check whether operating cash flow (OCF) is growing in line with profits. Then, examine free cash flow (FCF) after capital expenditure, does the company generate surplus cash? If profits are rising but cash flow isn’t, it could signal hidden stress or working capital inefficiencies.
Check footnotes & segment details
Always read the notes to accounts and segment-wise details, these often reveal insights that headline numbers don’t. For instance, changes in segment margins may highlight which business units are under pressure.
Look for one-off items like tax reversals or asset sales listed under ‘other income’. These can inflate reported profits but don’t reflect operational growth. For example, if a company’s profit spike is due to selling a factory, that’s not sustainable growth.
Compare performance with peers
Always compare a company’s results with those of its peers to understand its position in the sector. If the overall industry is performing well, but the company in question is seeing margin compression or weak growth, it may indicate poor management or inefficiencies.
This comparison helps you distinguish between sector-wide trends and company-specific performance.
Understand what’s driving revenue
Break down revenue by business units or geographic regions. Is growth driven by volume increases or simply higher pricing? Watch for seasonality or one-off events like festival sales or promotional deals.
Red flags not to be ignored
Spotting red flags is crucial to avoiding poor investments. Here are some important ones to watch out for:
Delayed results disclosure: Missing reporting deadlines or releasing results late at night, on weekends, or during holidays may be a sign the company is concealing bad news.
Poor corporate governance: Promoter share pledging, revenue leakage, stock price manipulation, or neglect of minority shareholders are warning signs.
Pending legal or tax cases: Ongoing lawsuits against the company or its directors can damage reputation and financial stability.
Inconsistent revenues: Sharp, unexplained swings in revenue or profit — excluding sectors like commodities — can indicate weak fundamentals.
Rising debt-to-equity ratio: Increasing debt without proportional earnings growth may suggest unsustainable expansion.
Complex or unusual transactions: Overly complicated deals might be masking losses or manipulating earnings.
Gross margins rising while sales fall: This mismatch could signal aggressive cost-cutting or questionable accounting practices.
Unusual accounting policies: Sudden changes in depreciation, revenue recognition, or expense reporting without explanation can obscure actual performance.
Too good to be true: A dramatic profit rise without corresponding business growth deserves scrutiny.
Auditor’s red flags: Carefully read audit reports for ‘qualified opinions’ or long lists of discrepancies.
Frequent changes in reporting policies: Regular tweaks to accounting methods can signal earnings manipulation.
Suspicious related-party transactions: Selling to group companies or unknown entities to artificially inflate revenue can indicate foul play.
Wrapping Up
By combining context with numbers and taking a disciplined approach, investors can go beyond surface-level data and make smarter, more confident decisions.
(The author is Vice President- Research, Teji Mandi)