JOIN USUkraine crisis could add to problems facing US economy
Russia’s attack on Ukraine could have economic repercussions globally and in the United States, ramping up uncertainty, roiling commodity markets and potentially pushing up inflation as gas and food prices rise around the world.
Russia is a major producer of oil and natural gas, and the geopolitical conflict has sent prices of both sharply higher in recent weeks. It is also the world’s largest wheat exporter and is a major food supplier to Europe.
The United States imports relatively little directly from Russia, but a commodities crunch caused by the conflict could have knock-on effects that at least temporarily drive up prices for raw materials and finished goods when much of the world, including the United States, is experiencing rapid inflation.
Global unrest could also spook US consumers, prompting them to cut back on spending and other economic activity. If the slowdown were to become severe, it could make it harder for the Federal Reserve, which is planning to raise interest rates in March, to decide how quickly and how aggressively to increase borrowing costs. Central bankers noted in minutes from their most recent meeting that geopolitical risks “could cause increases in global energy prices or exacerbate global supply shortages,” but also that they were a risk to the outlook for growth.
The magnitude of the potential economic fallout is unclear, because the scope and scale of the conflict remain anything but certain. But a foreign conflict could further delay a return to normalcy after two years in which the coronavirus pandemic has buffeted both the global and US economies. Tension between Russia and Ukraine is escalating when US consumers are already contending with quickly rising prices, businesses are trying to navigate roiled supply chains, and people report feeling pessimistic about their financial outlooks despite strong economic growth.
“The level of economic uncertainty is going to rise, which is going to be negative for households and firms,” said Maurice Obstfeld, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics. He noted that the effect would be felt most acutely in Europe and to a lesser degree in the United States.
A major and immediate economic implication of the showdown in Eastern Europe ties back to oil and gas. Russia produces 10 million barrels of oil a day, roughly 10 per cent of global demand, and is Europe’s largest supplier of natural gas, which is used to fuel power plants and provide heat to homes and businesses.
The United States imports comparatively little Russian oil, but energy commodity markets are global, meaning a change in prices in one part of the world influences how much people pay for energy elsewhere. It is unclear how much a conflict would push up prices, but energy markets have already been jittery — and fuel prices have risen sharply — on the prospect of an invasion.
If oil increases to $120 per barrel by the end of February, past the $95 mark it hovered around last week, inflation, as measured by the Consumer Price Index, could climb close to 9 per cent in the next few months, instead of a projected peak of a little below 8 per cent, said Alan Detmeister, an economist at UBS who formerly led the prices and wages section at the Fed. “It becomes a question of: How long do oil prices, natural gas wholesale prices stay elevated?” he said. “That’s anybody’s guess.”
The $120 per barrel mark for oil is a reasonable estimate of how high prices could go, said Patrick De Haan, head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy. That would translate to roughly $4 per gallon at the pump on average, he said.
Oil may be the major story when it comes to the inflationary effects of a Russian conflict, but it is not the only one. Ukraine is also a significant producer of uranium, titanium, iron ore, steel and ammonia, and a major source of Europe’s arable land.
Christian Bogmans, an economist at the International Monetary Fund, said a conflict in Ukraine could further inflate global food prices, which were set to stabilise after skyrocketing last year.
Russia and Ukraine together are responsible for nearly 30 per cent of global wheat exports, while Ukraine alone accounts for more than 15 per cent of global corn exports, he said. And many of Ukraine’s growing regions for wheat and corn are near the Russian border.
The rising price of gas and fertilizer, as well as droughts and adverse weather in some regions, like the Dakotas, had already helped to push up the global price of wheat and other commodities. Ukraine is also a significant producer of barley and vegetable oil, which goes into many packaged foods. “In case of a conflict, production might be interrupted, and shipping may be affected as well,” Bogmans said. If other countries impose sanctions on Russian food items, that could further limit global supplies and inflate prices, he said.
But because food costs make up a small portion of inflation, that may not matter as much to overall price data, Detmeister at UBS said. It is also hard to guess exactly how import prices would shape up because of the potential for currency movements.
If a conflict drives global uncertainty and causes investors to pour money into dollars, pushing up the value of the currency, it could make US imports cheaper.
There could also be other indirect effects on the economy, including rattling consumer confidence.
Households are sitting on cash stockpiles and probably could afford higher prices at the pump, but climbing energy costs are likely to make consumers unhappy when prices overall are already climbing and economic sentiment has swooned.
“The hit would be easily absorbed, but it would make consumers even more miserable, and we have to assume that a war in Europe would depress confidence directly, too,” Ian Shepherdson at Pantheon Macroeconomics wrote in a February 15 note.
Another risk to American economic activity may be underrated, Obstfeld said: The threat of cyberattack. Russia could respond to sanctions from the United States with digital retaliation, roiling digital life at a time when the internet has become central to economic existence.
“The Russians are the best in the world at this,” he said. “And we don’t know the extent to which they have burrowed into our systems.”
Watch the latest DH Videos here: