Towards an affordable CAR-T therapy

The parallel between the Trojan War and CAR-T therapy is striking. Like the wooden Trojan Horse concealing elite warriors in its belly, CAR-T therapy employs genetically reprogrammed live T lymphocytes, acting as warriors within the body, navigating to cancer cells and eradicating them.
Last Updated : 09 June 2024, 00:04 IST
Last Updated : 09 June 2024, 00:04 IST
Last Updated : 09 June 2024, 00:04 IST
Last Updated : 09 June 2024, 00:04 IST

Follow Us :


In 2006, a post-doctoral researcher delivered groundbreaking news to Prof Carl June at Penn Medical School in the USA, marking the beginning of an innovative approach to cancer treatment known as CAR-T therapy. The researchers had administered CAR-T cells (engineered white blood cells called Lymphocytes transformed into killer cells targeting cancer cells), into a mouse model half a year prior. Upon examination, the CAR-T had effectively killed the cancer cells. In 2010, five-year-old Emily Whitehead was diagnosed with Acute Lymphoblastic Leukaemia (ALL). Despite conventional treatments, her condition worsened. Her parents opted for a clinical trial with CAR-T at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia in April 2012, which successfully cured her leukaemia.

What is CAR-T?

The parallel between the Trojan War and CAR-T therapy is striking. Like the wooden Trojan Horse concealing elite warriors in its belly, CAR-T therapy employs genetically reprogrammed live T lymphocytes, acting as warriors within the body, navigating to cancer cells and eradicating them. CAR-T cell therapy, often referred to as the “longest-living drug” demonstrates remarkable longevity in patients. Even some individuals who received CAR-T infusions as far back as 2010 continue to have CAR-T cells persisting.

Targeted treatment

Traditionally, cancer treatment relied on surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation. Targeted therapies using molecular alterations in cancer cells have since emerged, alongside immunotherapy, which bolster the immune system to fight tumours, marking a significant shift in cancer treatment approaches. Blood contains white blood cells, crucial for combating infections and cancer. Within these, T Lymphocytes play a pivotal role in orchestrating the immune response. CAR-T therapy is personalised for each patient, involving the collection of T cells from the
patient, followed by laboratory re-engineering to express receptors targeting antigens like (CD19) on tumour cells.

Laboratory-engineered T cells are expanded to millions and then infused back into the patient. If successful, these CAR-T cells continue to multiply in the patient’s body and recognise and kill the cancer cells through the engineered receptors attached. Since 2017, six CAR-T cell therapies have been approved by the FDA for treating blood cancers including lymphomas, some forms of leukaemia, and more recently multiple myeloma. The cost factor has been one of the biggest criticisms about CAR-T therapy, the most recently approved one costing more than $450,000.

Indian CAR-T

In response to the challenges faced by cancer patients with relapsing ALL who are unresponsive to chemotherapy and have limited treatment options, Prof Gaurav Narula, a paediatric oncologist at Tata Memorial Hospital, (TMH) Mumbai, collaborated with Dr Rahul Purwar, a researcher from IIT Bombay. Since 2015, Rahul has been devoted to developing CAR-T therapy domestically in India. After gaining insights from the National Institute of Health in Bethesda, Maryland, USA, the team successfully designed an effective CAR-T cell therapy named actalycabtagene autoleucel (NexCAR19). This therapy is customised to address the healthcare needs of India and can be locally manufactured at an estimated cost of $50,000. ImmunoACT, the spin-off company of IIT Bombay, will oversee manufacturing for the Indian market. Initial short-term follow-up following the CAR-T infusions to patients with Lymphoma and Leukaemia (ALL) have shown promising results says Dr Hasmukh Jain from TMH who presented the findings at the annual meeting in the USA. Recently, the president of India dedicated to the country the homegrown NexCAR19. Dr Gaurav highlights the challenging decision to pursue indigenous development for this CAR-T, which granted them an end-to-end capacity and a foothold in the cell and gene therapy field, fostering collaborations between academia and industry.

Lauding the efforts, Dr Sattva Neelapu, a professor at the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Centre, Houston, USA, who led a key trial resulting in the first CAR-T approval for lymphoma in the USA, sees Indian CAR-T as a significant step forward, boosting biotech investment in the field.

Decentralised option

Under the guidance of Dr Vikram Mathews, Director of CMC Vellore, researchers have embarked on a decentralised approach to CAR-T cell manufacturing. They utilise a fully automated and closed Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) compliant device called CliniMACS Prodigy, developed by Miltenyi Biotec,
Germany. Dr Vikram sees the advantage of producing CAR-T cells at the point of care using the CliniMACS Prodigy, ensuring adherence to required standards.

Dr Sridhar Chaganti, programme director at the University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Trust’s CAR-T programme, views local CAR-T incubators as an option for large
academic centres treating large numbers of patients but emphasises the requirement for a regulatory framework ensuring the quality testing of the product and assigning accountability to whoever is holding the license of manufacturing.

Treating large patient numbers at one centre poses challenges. Dr Vikram envisions establishing a decentralised model across major tertiary care centres nationwide to meet patient needs. Additionally, the same automated CliniMacs Prodigy platform could potentially deliver gene therapies in the future for diseases like Thalassemia major and Sickle cell disease.

Failure & complications

CAR-T treatment may fail for several reasons. Dr Sattva explains it can occur if the targeted antigen in the tumour is reduced or if the T cells become less functional due to the chemotherapies patients receive or due to the immune suppressive effect of the tumour on T cells.

Additionally, the treatment is linked to complications like Cytokine Release Syndrome (CRS) or a surge of inflammation and neurological toxicity. The treatment has an overall mortality rate of 10-12%. Prolonged immune suppression from the treatment can lead to infections such as pneumonia and viral infections. Dr Sridhar advises informing patients about these risks and the potential need for protein concentrate (Immunoglobulin) administration to mitigate infection risks that can increase the cost of overall care.

(Dr Praveen Kumar Kaudlay is a consultant haemato-oncologist with a special interest in stem cell transplantation at Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust, UK. He can be reached at praveen.kaudlay1@nhs.net while Dr Swaminathan P Iyer, is MD,  professor of Lymphoma and Myeloma at the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, Texas, USA: spiyer@mdanderson.org.)

Published 09 June 2024, 00:04 IST

Follow us on :

Follow Us