JOIN USMillions of Brazilians face dire poverty if Covid-19 emergency payments stop
Brazil managed to alleviate poverty with emergency payments during the Covid-19 pandemic, but if government income support efforts are not continued 15 million Brazilians will be thrown back into dire poverty come January, an economist warned on Thursday.
Extension of the generous subsidies is stalled in Congress and faces some opposition from within the government whose economic policy team worries about an uncontrolled budget deficit.
"We're between a rock and a hard place," economist Marcelo Neri, head of social policies at the FGV higher education think tank in Rio de Janeiro, told Reuters.
An FGV study published on Thursday said the number of poor Brazilians, those that earn less than half of a minimum wage, or 515 reais ($92) per month, fell 23.7% to a new low of 50 million people thanks to the monthly payments that started at 600 reais, but have now been cut to 300 reais and expire on Dec. 31.
Far-right President Jair Bolsonaro, whose popularity has risen thanks to the hand-outs, is scrambling to find a way to maintain payments, but there is no way to fund them without breaking a constitutional spending cap and worsening a run-away budget deficit.
Brazil was more generous than other Latin American nations with its poor during the pandemic even though its fiscal situation was worse; although Economy Minister Paulo Guedes was trying to keep his fiscal austerity drive on track, Neri said.
"Guedes turned out to be a surprisingly generous manager of Keynesian policies. Now, we have to continue being half Keynesian, but we don't have the money," Neri said.
Brazil, which had seen large-scale capital flight from the Sao Paulo stock market earlier this year, risks rattling investors further if it boosts spending too much in 2021, the Princeton University-trained economist warned.
The Covid-19 payments will have cost the Treasury 321.8 billion reais ($57.6 billion) by year's end.
A member of the congressional joint budget committee, Senator Ney Suassuna, told Reuters there was no consensus on how to pay for income support next year even as the pandemic crisis is expected to continue with scant improvement of the labour market.
Like in most of Latin America, the pandemic has reduced the size of the traditional middle class, with 4.8 million Brazilians slipping down due to lost income, Neri said.
Millions of middle-class Latin Americans are being dragged into poverty by the Covid-19 outbreak, which has hit the region's labour market harder than elsewhere in the world. Poverty is set to surge back to 2005 levels in Latin America.
"It's a terrible anguish, to get to my age ... to have brought up two sons, and today I have no way to look after myself," said Maria Lucia Spolzino Porto, an unemployed mother who moved in with her adult son. "I don't have a house, I don't have a job. I live from the help my son is giving today."