Press Esc to close
Friday 23 June 2017
News updated at 7:17 PM IST

Child labour: A necessary evil?

By Vatsala Vedantam 0:35 IST
In July 1995, a document concerning India was tabled in the US House of Representatives, which said: “There exists a little-known human rights problem in India, which is very grave. This problem is the exploitation of child labour. The United States government and the international community have paid little attention to the prolific employment of young children. It is time to attend to this neglect.”

India has always been the whipping boy for several ills. Enforced child labour is only one of them. Bride burning, dowry deaths, child marriage, bonded labour, money laundering, drug peddling. The list is endless. Today, the US government again indicts India among countries that use child labour in their garment factories which will surely hurt the interests of garment manufacturers and their workers by reducing the flow of orders from America. It is surprising that the western world –especially America – is not perturbed by multinational companies such as Reebok, Nike, and Levis Strauss and others which are exploiting human labour in developing countries like India massively. These companies are called sweatshops. According to the UN Committee on Trade and Development, these child labourers “work under inhumane conditions and barely earn a pittance for producing thousands of products worth hundreds of dollars.” It adds that developing countries are booming because of massive direct foreign investment while workers suffer degrading working conditions and low wages.

Inhuman treatment


According to a recent survey, India remains the most preferred outsourcing destination by large private American corporations, with over 60 per cent of the market share in the US. Speaking of multinationals exploiting children, ‘The Economist’ carried an article ‘Sweating for Fashion’ which says “Nike, for example, has been accused of using child labour in Cambodia; Adidas of using prison labour in China; Benetton of using child workers in Turkey.” Where is the public outrage, where are the tears by human rights organisations in India and abroad for this kind of inhumanity? Why cry foul only at those children in the fireworks factories of Sivakasi; the diamond polishing factories of Surat, the silk reeling yards in Karnataka or the carpet weaving godowns of Punjab? They have made world headlines (and blockbuster films too) even though it has not reduced the sale of crackers or diamonds or silk or carpets in countries which condemn the practice.

At least, the families of such children have accepted the fact that the younger generation must carry on the family trade. They don’t shed false tears for their children. The sons and daughters of weavers, goldsmiths, tailors, carpenters and similar professions specialise in those skills which their ancestors practiced. They do not think that their children are abused. They have merely passed on a legacy to them.

The problem of child labour is a complex issue, something that cannot be solved through legislation or with simplistic solutions. It is driven mainly out of poverty and in societies where women have limited choices in questions of marriage or family planning. Desperate for money, and unable to feed their families, they sometimes inevitably place their offspring in bonded labour or worse. The next best thing they can do is to hand over the elder siblings to factories, hotels or even homes where they are assured of at least one proper meal every day.

In big cities, the most sought after places are building construction sites and industries which find that employing children is cheap and easy to handle. So also are small business houses like tailoring shops, retail cloth stores, automobile repair garages. Children find jobs here in return for small salaries and a few meals a day. If deprived of these, they may turn to more undesirable professions like begging and prostitution. Their parents argue, and rightly so, that they are learning skills which may enable them to set up businesses of their own later. Alternately. what use is a school education ending with a useless school leaving certificate that leaves a youngster unskilled and unemployable?

This does not mean we should perpetuate child labour. It is a question of what viable alternatives can governments offer before legislating for its ban. Far better to let a child work and earn for his family while learning skills himself, rather than turn to begging or thieving or worse. NGOs speak of child rights. Other countries denounce this obnoxious practice. What alternate feasible solutions do they offer for a country with a billion plus population where 40 per cent is illiterate, much of it living below the poverty line? Child labour cannot be wished away in international seminars or with thundering speeches. Unless and until we find suitable alternatives through a more meaningful education system, our children will continue to stitch Nike shoes or Levis jeans — if not reeling silk, polishing diamonds, weaving carpets or rolling firecrackers.

Go to Top

Photo Gallery
Telugu actor Allu Arjun speaks during promotion of the film'DJ' in Bengaluru on Thursday...

Telugu actor Allu Arjun speaks during promotion of the film'DJ' in Bengaluru on Thursday...

A woman gingerly makes her way through a flooded road in Guwahati after heavy rains...

A woman gingerly makes her way through a flooded road in Guwahati after heavy rains...

A man jumps into Lake Walensee, with the Churfristen mountain range in the background...

A man jumps into Lake Walensee, with the Churfristen mountain range in the background...

A man sketches a portrait of Hindi Lord Shiva to earn money alongside a road in Kolkata...

A man sketches a portrait of Hindi Lord Shiva to earn money alongside a road in Kolkata...

A rhino with its calf at the Pobitora Wildlife Sanctuary in Morigaon district of Assam...

A rhino with its calf at the Pobitora Wildlife Sanctuary in Morigaon district of Assam...

An Icelandic horse shakes off flies in its paddock in Anspach near Frankfurt...

An Icelandic horse shakes off flies in its paddock in Anspach near Frankfurt...

The Namma Metro Train work is going on at R V Engeeniring College,Mysuru Road in Bengaluru...

The Namma Metro Train work is going on at R V Engeeniring College,Mysuru Road in Bengaluru...

Portugal's Cristiano Ronaldo attends a training session at the Spartak Stadium in Moscow, Russia...

Portugal's Cristiano Ronaldo attends a training session at the Spartak Stadium in Moscow, Russia...

A helicopter drops water as U.S. Forest Service firefighters and several other departments battle...

A helicopter drops water as U.S. Forest Service firefighters and several other departments battle...

A tiger licks a block of ice containing chicken parts offered by zoo keepers during the summer...

A tiger licks a block of ice containing chicken parts offered by zoo keepers during the summer...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.