Press Esc to close
Saturday 19 August 2017
News updated at 8:45 AM IST

SC refuses to issue directions on CMC's order

New Delhi, Dec 10, 2012, DHNS 1:13 IST

Judges ask Karnataka to comply with order

File Photo
The Supreme Court on Monday refused to consider Tamil Nadu’s plea contending that the 12 tmcft of water that the Cauvery Monitoring Committee (CMC) has ordered Karnataka to release was insufficient even as it ruled that Karnataka must comply with the order.

A bench of Justices D K Jain and Madan B Lokur, however, noted that the CMC’s December 7 order is subject to appropriate legal remedy to which Karnataka submitted that it would challenge the order before the Cauvery River Authority (CRA) headed by the Prime Minister.

“It seems that both states are not satisfied with the directions issued by the CMC. Without commenting on the directions, we leave it to the parties to work out in accordance with the law. Subject to appropriate remedy, the state (Karnataka) shall comply with the directions,” the bench said.

Additional Solicitor General H P Raval submitted that the Centre is ready to notify the Cauvery Water Dispute Tribunal’s (CWDT) final decision announced on February 5, 2007.
He was responding to the court’s question as to when the government would notify the CWDT’s decision to resolve the controversial issue of water sharing between Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Kerala and Puducherry.

Senior advocate C S Vaidynathan, appearing for Tamil Nadu, said the CMC had ignored “factual” aspects of the state’s water requirements for its standing samba crop. “Both states have shortage, let’s equalise the available water as per the need,” he said.

Representing Karnataka, senior advocate Anil Divan said Tamil Nadu’s plea could not be allowed and they should challenge the order before the Cauvery River Authority.

Remedy

“We should not comment on the CMC’s order. The report of the CMC is not binding on us, it is a different issue. Karnataka is also aggrieved (with the order), they have to work out their remedy,” the bench said.

Vaidynathan insisted that the CMC had ignored the state’s need. The court told him: “You file an affidavit or whatever you wish to…we will consider it.”

To this, Vaidyanathan submitted that the court should issue direction to Karnataka to comply with the direction given by the CMC immediately.

His contention was strongly objected to by Divan. However, the court said both states could take legal recourse and posted the matter for further hearing for January 4.

Go to Top

Photo Gallery
A  file photo of  Infosys CEO Vishal Sikka...

A file photo of Infosys CEO Vishal Sikka...

Trainee recruits of Army undergo physical training at the Parachute Regiment Training...

Trainee recruits of Army undergo physical training at the Parachute Regiment Training...

A Chimpanzee looks on, at Alipore Zoological Garden in Kolkata...

A Chimpanzee looks on, at Alipore Zoological Garden in Kolkata...

A beautiful view of peacock on blooming tree branch at Bengre in Mangaluru...

A beautiful view of peacock on blooming tree branch at Bengre in Mangaluru...

People with their household belongings move to a relief camp from a flood-hit region...

People with their household belongings move to a relief camp from a flood-hit region...

Village women carry a Tri-colour as they row a boat across River Churni during Independence...

Village women carry a Tri-colour as they row a boat across River Churni during Independence...

An aerial view of a flood-hit area at Bal Bal in Betiah in West Chaparan, Bihar...

An aerial view of a flood-hit area at Bal Bal in Betiah in West Chaparan, Bihar...

A boy rows a makeshift raft as he transports a woman and a cooking gas cylinder through...

A boy rows a makeshift raft as he transports a woman and a cooking gas cylinder through...

A fruit vendor, holding an umbrella, waits for customers at a street in Kolkata on Thursday.

A fruit vendor, holding an umbrella, waits for customers at a street in Kolkata on Thursday.

Ranbir Kapoor, actor and co-owner Mumbai City FC meeting fans during the Indian Super League...

Ranbir Kapoor, actor and co-owner Mumbai City FC meeting fans during the Indian Super League...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.