Press Esc to close

Govt's vitamin-A project fails to save dying children

New Delhi, Mar 18, 2013, DHNS: 1:36 IST

Expert opinion against continuing costly programme was ignored

Giving vitamin A supplements orally to babies and pre-school children does not save them from death even though the government spends crores in buying and supplying these vitamin drops all over India.

Carried out on two million school children from 8,000 towns in Uttar Pradesh for five years, a new study has found no significant difference in death rate between those who received the oral vitamin A supplements and those who did not. “It contradicts the expectation from other trials that vitamin A supplementation would reduce child mortality by 20-30 per cent. No specific cause of death was significantly affected,” says the study published in March 16 issue of the medical journal Lancet.

The finding supports views held by a section of Indian doctors who felt scarce resources were wasted by the government in procuring and supplying vitamin A to children. Vitamin A supplement was given since 1970s to counter nutritional blindness in children up to 5 years. But as the food and nutrition situation improves in the next two decades, an Indian Council of Medical Research expert group suggested in 2005 to restrict the supplement for children between 9 months and three years.

The Centre, however, ignored the expert panel's advice and continued with vitamin A supplements to children up to 5 years arguing it would increase their chances of survival from other diseases.

The DEVTA (De-worming and Enhanced Vitamin A) trial results now suggests barely any benefits for children who received the vitamin A drops. In certain cases the results showed marginal improvements, which can be explained by other factors. Many public health officials had earlier questioned the vitamin A supplement policy claiming adverse side effects.

In the Lancet paper, the team demonstrated while the effect of supplementation was not absolutely nil, it was certainly not as high as 20-30 per cent as claimed by previous research. The effect could be a quarter of half (between 5 and 15 per cent) of the past claims, according to the researchers including a team from King George Medical University in Lucknow.

“The trial estimates mortality reduction at 4 per cent, ranging from an 11 per cent reduction to 3 per cent increase. It creates uncertainty around this intervention—or at least uncertainty around the effect size that has been attributed to vitamin A up until now,” says an accompanying comment in the same issue of Lancet written by three independent doctors including veteran Indian paediatrician H P S Sachdev, who is not involved with DEVTA trial. “Mortality is generally evaluated as an important justification for vitamin A intervention. But there was no evidence of mortality reduction in the trial,” Sachdev told Deccan Herald from Geneva.

Incidentally, even though the research was completed by 2007, the team took almost six years to publish the data giving rise to speculations among the public health community on the role played by the “Vitamin-A lobby” in the delay.

Go to Top

Photo Gallery
Indian Air force paratroopers perform maneuvers at Bamhrauli Air station as the Indian Air Force ...

Indian Air force paratroopers perform maneuvers at Bamhrauli Air station as the Indian Air Force ...

Indian Mens Hockey team celebrates their birth in the final of the Hero Asia Cup 2017 with a...

Indian Mens Hockey team celebrates their birth in the final of the Hero Asia Cup 2017 with a...

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on the maiden voyage of Ro-Ro Ferry Service between Ghogha and Dahej...

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on the maiden voyage of Ro-Ro Ferry Service between Ghogha and Dahej...

India's Kuldeep Yadav celebrates the wicket of New Zealand batsman Kane Williamson during the...

India's Kuldeep Yadav celebrates the wicket of New Zealand batsman Kane Williamson during the...

External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj with Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina at a ...

External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj with Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina at a ...

Spain's Garbine Muguruza in action during her group stage match against Latvia's Jelena Ostapenko...

Spain's Garbine Muguruza in action during her group stage match against Latvia's Jelena Ostapenko...

Meng Meng, one of the two giant Chinese panda bears, is seen at the Zoo in Berlin, Germany July 5...

Meng Meng, one of the two giant Chinese panda bears, is seen at the Zoo in Berlin, Germany July 5...

Father Nicolas Maine blesses bikers' helmets during a

Father Nicolas Maine blesses bikers' helmets during a "Blessing of the Bikes" ceremony at Saint...

Arsenal's Sead Kolasinac in action with Everton's Nikola Vlasic during Premier League match at ...

Arsenal's Sead Kolasinac in action with Everton's Nikola Vlasic during Premier League match at ...

A volunteer uses a water hose to fight a wildfire near houses on the outskirts of Obidos...

A volunteer uses a water hose to fight a wildfire near houses on the outskirts of Obidos...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.