Press Esc to close

DoT critical of CAG remark on telcos cartel

Ajith Athrady, New Delhi, July 17, 2013, DHNS; 2:18 IST

Ministry wants Competition Commission to address issue

The Department of Telecom (DoT) is likely to have a fresh spat with the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) over the latter’s criticism against the government that it failed to stop telecom companies from forming a cartel.

This allegedly led to failure of the last two radio spectrum auctions, depriving the exchequer of huge revenues.

Apart from urging the CAG to drop the key observation, the DoT is likely to tell the national auditor that the Competition Commission of India (CCI) will address the cartelisation issue and not the CAG. “As the CCI is the competent authority to address the issue of cartelisation, we will tell the CAG the same,” sources in the DoT told Deccan Herald.

DoT has been fighting against the CAG ever since its observation that the exchequer suffered a Rs 1.76 lakh crore loss in the spectrum auction. It will submit its reply to the auditing body saying that the word “cartelisation” should be dropped, sources said.

Earlier, the CAG, in its observation on the “failed” auction, said cartelisation by telecom companies was the main reason for the failure of the recent auction of telecom spectrum and criticised the government for its failure to take action against erring companies.

In November 2012, when the government put on sale the spectrum, it garnered only Rs 13,046 crore as against the targeted Rs 40,000 crore due to the lack of interest among the telecom companies. Even in the March 2013 auction, only one company, Sistema Shyam Teleservices, participated and the government got Rs 3,639 crore.

DG (Audit) Post and Telecommunications, an unit of the CAG, said: “Apparent cartelisation by the telecom service providers observed recently in the last two spectrum auctions, wittingly or unwittingly aided and abetted by the inaction/delayed action of the licensor... have already cost the government very dearly as tranches of spectrum valued at hundreds of billions of rupees were left unsold.”

The lukewarm response to the auction led to suspicion that some telecom companies worked together to manipulate the outcome and compel the government to reduce reserve price of the spectrum. Before the auction started, many telecom companies openly said the reserve price was too high and it would not be economically viable for them to participate in the bidding.

The CAG report, if published with the allegations, would be damning for the telecom department, sources said. “The government does not want to repeat the damage it had faced in the 2G spectrum allocations in 2008,” they said.

Go to Top

More from this section
Most trending stories
Photo Gallery
Bollywood actress and BJP MP Hema Malini performs during 'Braj Holi Raso Utsav' in Mathura...

Bollywood actress and BJP MP Hema Malini performs during 'Braj Holi Raso Utsav' in Mathura...

Children play with 'gulal' ahead of Holi festival in Kolkata on Sunday...

Children play with 'gulal' ahead of Holi festival in Kolkata on Sunday...

The Indian cricket team pose for a photo with their trophy after beating South Africa in the...

The Indian cricket team pose for a photo with their trophy after beating South Africa in the...

File Photo of Bollywood superstar Sridevi Kapoor, receiving Padma Shri from the then President...

File Photo of Bollywood superstar Sridevi Kapoor, receiving Padma Shri from the then President...

A bird feeds on the seasonal flowers at Dudhnai in Assam states Goalpara District on...

A bird feeds on the seasonal flowers at Dudhnai in Assam states Goalpara District on...

Canadian short-track speed skater Kim Boutin leads team Canada into the Olympic stadium...

Canadian short-track speed skater Kim Boutin leads team Canada into the Olympic stadium...

Sridevi fans wait outside her residence at Lokhandwala Complex, in Andheri, north-west, Mumbai...

Sridevi fans wait outside her residence at Lokhandwala Complex, in Andheri, north-west, Mumbai...

Men and women play 'Lathmaar Holi' on the occasion of Fag Mahoutsav at historical Govind Dev Ji...

Men and women play 'Lathmaar Holi' on the occasion of Fag Mahoutsav at historical Govind Dev Ji...

Students take a selfie during Holi celebration in Visva-Bharati University Campus at Sriniketan...

Students take a selfie during Holi celebration in Visva-Bharati University Campus at Sriniketan...

People celebrate Latthmaar Holi in Barsana near Mathura on Saturday...

People celebrate Latthmaar Holi in Barsana near Mathura on Saturday...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.