Press Esc to close
Wednesday 27 September 2017
News updated at 1:30 AM IST

CSIR sacks scientists for unprofessional conduct

Last updated: 09 November, 2009
Kalyan Ray , New Delhi, Nov 8, DHNS 1:01 IST

Confidential documents leaked in violation of service rule

The Council of Scientific and Industrial Researchs (CSIR) ambitious plan to create an in-house firm for marketing its own technologies is in rough waters following the removal of two scientists chosen to pilot the venture.

The duo was sacked on November 5 following “unprofessional conduct” and for leaking out confidential documents in violation of service rules.

V A Shiva Ayyadurai, a graduate from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), and Deepak Sardana, who worked as consultant for CSIR, were chosen to pilot the new company –– CSIR Tech.

The Union Cabinet had given its approval for establishing the new firm in January 2009.
Shiva met CSIR director general Samir K Brahmachari in June. Impressed by his credentials, Brahmachari decided to retain the MIT graduate under a new scheme “Scientists and Technologist of Indian Origin (STIO)”.

Brahmachari’s idea was to eventually appoint Shiva as the CEO of CSIR-Tech when the company is finally set up.

Since STIO recruitment takes time –– approval from higher authorities as well as medical and Intelligence Bureau (IB) clearances are required –– Shiva was offered a temporary job as a business development consultant with Rs 1 lakh salary. The MIT-trained researcher accepted the offer and joined CSIR as a consultant.

Documents available with Deccan Herald show that the organisation relaxed its internal norms to arrange an accommodation for Shiva. Also in the accommodation letter they mistakenly mentioned that Shiva had been selected and appointed as an STIO.
Actually Shiva was only “offered” the STIO position. He was never appointed as he did not agree to the terms and conditions, did not have its medical and IB clearance and an Indian work permit required for a full-time job.

The STIO offer was withdrawn in October due to Shiva’s demand of an “unreasonable financial package.”

But, meanwhile, as a consultant on CSIR Tech, he had met a number of scientists in the last four months and finally prepared a report controversial titled “CSIR-Tech: Path Forward.” The report stirred a hornet’s nest.

In the 42-page document Shiva and Sardana described Brahmachari as the “director general who believes he knows all even though he has minimal depth of information and domain knowledge.”

The duo accused Brahmachari of “maintaining a close coterie of sycophants, mostly incompetent” and not allowing the opposition views for any debate. The report –– mailed to almost 4000 CSIR scientists accessing a proprietary database the duo was not authorised to use –– literally stirred the entire organisation from Kashmir to
Kanyakumari.

Almost all CSIR laboratories came down heavily on the two newcomers with six months experience for denigrating the 67-year old organisation and its chief. South African consultant Ian Dean, who was quoted in the report, readily distanced himself from the document and deplored “the attack on director general and headquarters staff.” A senior CSIR scientist in Pune described it as a “slanderous report written with a malicious intention to discredit the CSIR leadership.”

Another scientist in Jammu accused Shiva of making “unsubstantiated and frivolous charges.” But a third senior CSIR scientist in Palampur opined that such behaviour “cannot be tolerated in any set up in India or in a multinational corporation.” He also alleged Shiva had personal motives rather than realising the CSIR-Tech vision. However, Shiva and Sardana claimed they were victimised because of their critical report.

Go to Top

Photo Gallery
Reliance Group Chairman Anil Ambani with his son...

Reliance Group Chairman Anil Ambani with his son...

Ajey Mehta, vice president- India, HMD Global, Pranav Shroff...

Ajey Mehta, vice president- India, HMD Global, Pranav Shroff...

Chinese President Xi Jinping speaks during the 86th Interpol General Assembly...

Chinese President Xi Jinping speaks during the 86th Interpol General Assembly...

Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman and U. S. Defence Secretary...

Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman and U. S. Defence Secretary...

Congress vice president Rahul Gandhi waves at...

Congress vice president Rahul Gandhi waves at...

Police personnel baton charge on the Indira Gandhi Institute of Medical...

Police personnel baton charge on the Indira Gandhi Institute of Medical...

Union Minister of Finance Arun Jaitley with Managing Director & CEO of Axis Bank...

Union Minister of Finance Arun Jaitley with Managing Director & CEO of Axis Bank...

Flag Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Western Naval...

Flag Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Western Naval...

Army Chief Gen Bipin Rawat before attending the...

Army Chief Gen Bipin Rawat before attending the...

Australian Cricketer Glen Maxwell preopares to bat...

Australian Cricketer Glen Maxwell preopares to bat...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.