Press Esc to close

2G judgement: CBI fails again

DH News Service, Bengaluru, Dec 23 2017, 0:08 IST

The acquittal of all the accused, including former telecom minister A Raja and DMK leader Kanimozhi, in the 2G scam case is a slap in the face of the CBI, which investigated the case. It is also a stinging comment on the prosecution, which failed to establish the case before the court. The special court judge said that the CBI had failed to prove any wrongdoing and there was little by way of actual proof of the charges it made. The judge also said that the prosecution was "highly cautious and guarded" and became "directionless and diffident" towards the end. The 2G scam was termed the biggest in the country's history, with the then CAG reporting that the 2008 allocation of spectrum caused a loss of Rs 1.76 lakh crore to the exchequer. The CBI placed the loss at Rs 30,984 crore, but the court did not accept even that figure, and said that a scam was created by "artfully arranging a few facts" and "exaggerating things".

The charges related to violation of the first-come-first-serve policy, fixing an arbitrary cut-off date, granting of licence to ineligible companies, payment of a Rs 200 crore bribe to Kalaignar TV, and misleading the then prime minister Manmohan Singh. The court said that records presented to the court did not prove these charges. The first-come-first-serve policy was not a policy followed in all cases. There was no evidence to show that Rs 200 crore was paid as bribe. The prosecution did not question the witnesses in detail to get all the circumstances and the deficiencies in the documents explained. The court felt that a perception of wrongdoing was created by "rumour, gossip and speculation," but these have no place in judicial proceedings.

But the fact remains that there were irregularities, though enough evidence may not have been presented to the court. The Supreme Court had cancelled 122 licences, which had been wrongly awarded, though it may be argued that the issue before the court was not the conspiracy and the criminality involved in the allocation of licences. An examination of criminality has to be very rigorous, as the CBI court judge said, but there might be a view that he exercised too much judicial rigour. The judgement has raised many questions, and they may be answered by the higher courts where it will be contested. The Congress and the DMK have found some comfort but, as the final word is yet to be said, it will be unfortunate if the judgement strengthens the impression that highly placed persons can get away with corruption and violation of law.

Go to Top

More from this section
Most trending stories
Photo Gallery
Lesser flamingos seen at Aroli creek in Mumbai on Tuesday during winter...

Lesser flamingos seen at Aroli creek in Mumbai on Tuesday during winter...

Israeli boy Moshe Holtzberg, who lost his parents during the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks...

Israeli boy Moshe Holtzberg, who lost his parents during the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks...

Border Security Force (BSF)'s women daredevils perfom on motorcycles during a rehearsal...

Border Security Force (BSF)'s women daredevils perfom on motorcycles during a rehearsal...

BSF's marching contingent during a rehearsal for the Republic Day parade, in New Delhi....

BSF's marching contingent during a rehearsal for the Republic Day parade, in New Delhi....

Mauni baba along with his followers arrives to take holy dip at Sangam on the occasion...

Mauni baba along with his followers arrives to take holy dip at Sangam on the occasion...

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his wife Sara Netanyahu pose for a picture...

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his wife Sara Netanyahu pose for a picture...

India's Rohit Sharma, right, jumps as he celebrates with bowler Jasprit Bumrah...

India's Rohit Sharma, right, jumps as he celebrates with bowler Jasprit Bumrah...

Participants trying to tame a bull during the Alanganallur jallikattu in Madurai district...

Participants trying to tame a bull during the Alanganallur jallikattu in Madurai district...

U-19 cricket team coach Rahul Dravid in a group photo with Indian hockey team players...

U-19 cricket team coach Rahul Dravid in a group photo with Indian hockey team players...

pain's Carolina Marin of Hyderabad Hunters and Denmark's badminton player Viktor Axelsen...

pain's Carolina Marin of Hyderabad Hunters and Denmark's badminton player Viktor Axelsen...

Like us on Facebook

Copyright 2017, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bengaluru - 560001
Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523
Powered by Yodasoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.