Last Updated IST
Prime Minister Narendra Modi replies on the Motion of No-Confidence in the Lok Sabha in the Monsoon session of Parliament, in New Delhi, Thursday, Aug. 10, 2023.
Credit: PTI Photo
"There was nothing in Amit Shah's speech, it was an attempt to confuse people...PM did not speak a word on Manipur till that video went viral...seems like Amit Shah and BJP have no relation with Manipur...", says Congress leader Udit Raj.
"Flying Kiss': BJP's women MPs lodge complaint against Rahul Gandhi with Lok Sabha Speaker
Women MPs from the ruling BJP lodged a complaint against Rahul Gandhi with the Lok Sabha speaker’s office on Wednesday, alleging that the Wayanad MP blew a kiss at the treasury benches after his speech in the no-trust vote against the Modi government...
Read more
TMC terms Rahul's LS speech as 'straight from heart', slams Shah over Manipur
The TMC on Wednesday praised Congress leader Rahul Gandhi for raising the Manipur issue in Parliament by "speaking from the heart", and criticised Union Home Minister Amit Shah for attempting to "mask the Centre's failure" in the northeastern state with "feeble excuses".
"Rahul Gandhi addressed the core issues of the country. He spoke from his heart on the Manipur situation. It was straight from the heart. The entire country also feels the same. The central government has completely failed to control the situation, which he has pointed out in his speech," Trinamool Congress MP Sougata Roy told PTI.
Commenting on Amit Shah's speech in Parliament, Roy said the union minister made a "political speech to defend the indefensible".
PM Modi will today reply to the no-confidence motion moved by the Opposition parties in the Lok Sabha. The floor will also see the voting on the no-confidence motion.
On the allegation of MPs claiming that their names were mentioned on the proposal moved by AAP MP Raghav Chadha to send the Delhi NCT Amendment Bill to the Select Committee without their consent, AAP MP Raghav Chadha says "The rule book says that any MP can propose the name for the formation of any committee and neither the signature nor the written consent of the person whose name is proposed is required. But a lie was spread that forged signatures were done"
Parliament proceedings begin for the day.
On parts of Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's speech being expunged in the Lok Sabha yesterday, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Pralhad Joshi says, "...If anything unparliamentary is said it is expunged & it has been an old practice. This is nothing new..."
Opposition ruckus in Lok Sabha over Manipur.
Lok Sabha adjourned till 12 noon amid Oppn ruckus over Manipur.
Ahead of PM Modi's reply to no-confidence motion in Parliament, DMK MP Tiruchi Siva says, "We are expecting him to speak. As the head of the government, he will be coming today & we expect him to give a reply..."
Dhankhar plants a tree in Parliament
DMK leader Tiruchi Siva demands discussion on Manipur in the Lok Sabha, says "logjam prevailing for the last 15 days".
Ruckus mars Rajya Sabha proceedings as chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar appeals MPs to take their seats.
Leader of Opposition Mallikarjun Kharge appeals Rajya Sabha chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar to hold discussion on Manipur.
Rajya Sabha has been adjourned till 2 pm.
Lok Sabha proceedings resume.
Lok Sabha proceedings have begun with a relative calm after a breather as the House takes up Reports of Joint Committee on Offices of Profit.
Nirmala Sitharaman addresses Lok Sabha.
Morgan Stanley had declared India a 'fragile' economy in 2013, but now they have 'upgraded' us, says Nirmala Sitharaman.
We are succeeding in reducing poverty, says Nirmala Sitharaman.
'Modi, Modi' slogans reverberate in the Lok Sabha as Nirmala Sitharaman addresses the House.
We believe in empowerment of all and appeasement of none, says Nirmala Sitharaman in the Lok Sabha.
Nirmala Sitharaman lists out achievements of Modi government
"India had 74 airports in 2014, but now the number stands at 148"
"No waterways in India in 2014. But now the number stands at 111," says Sitharaman.
Sitharaman attacks the then UPA government, says they indulged in family politics, cronyism and corruption.
"Words like 'banega, milega' are not in use anymore. What are the people using these days? 'Ban gaye, mil gaye, aa gaye'. During UPA, people said 'Bijli aayegi', now people say 'Bijli aa gayi'. They said 'gas connection milega', now 'gas connection mil gaya'...They said airport 'banega', now airport 'ban gaya'...," says Nirmala Sitharaman.
"Transformation comes through actual delivery, and not through spoken words. You show dreams to people. We make their dreams a reality. We believe in empowering all and appeasement of none," Nirmala Sitharaman says.
"Our real GDP growth in 2022-23 stood at 7.2 per cent. It is projected to grow at 6.5 per cent in 2023-24. These projections are given by several global agencies, and our own RBI projection is also the same," says Sitharaman.
Clearing mess in banks created by UPA: Sitharaman
'Launch karne mein khushi hai, implement karne mein nahi,' says Sitharaman in swipe at the then UPA government over Jan Aushadhi campaign.
"We have realised that the banking sector needs to be healthy and therefore we took a lot of measures. Banks are able to work without political interference, they are working with professional integrity. 'Banks mein failaya hua aapka raita hum saaf kar rahe hai'...,"says Sitharaman in Lok Sabha.
Karnataka's Health Minister came to Delhi to see the mohalla clinics here. He came and said that there is nothing special in them and we are disappointed. This is one of the examples of their fight: Sitharaman
AIIMS is coming in Madurai: Sitharaman
Till 2014, there were 7 AIIMS in country, now there are 53: Sitharaman
Opposition sloganeering continues in the Lok Sabha as Sitharaman continues her address to the House.
Our DBT story sets an example for the rest of the world. I recognise the operationalisation of DBT by UPA but only Rs 7,367 crores were transferred in 2013-14. From that amount, DBT transfers have increased 5 times from 2014-15 itself. In the last financial year, Rs 7.16 lakh crores have been transferred through DBT: Sitharaman
"This is an extraordinary unity where it is difficult to understand whether the alliance partners are fighting amongst each other or fighting unitedly," says Union Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman the in Lok Sabha.
Sitharaman says Opposition-ruled states have not reduced the price of fuel as she goes on to mention the names of a few states including Rajasthan and Punjab among others.
Congress, NCP and DMK MPs stage a walk-out from the Lok Sabha as Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman speaks on the no-confidence motion.
The Finance Minister also listed out steps being taken by the government to contain tomato price rise while speaking in the Lok Sabha.
Sitharaman says procuring of tomatoes from tomato growing regions of Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka and distribution of these through cooperative societies like NCCF, NAFED are all happening. "Bihar, West Bengal, Uttar Pradesh, Delhi and Rajasthan - this has already started from July 14 and this will continue. Also in Delhi, mobile vans are distributing as outlets of NCCF and NAFED and also the Kendriya Bhandar."
FM on steps taken by Centre to contain tomato price rise
As on date, NCCF has distributed 8,84,612 kgs of tomatoes in Rajasthan, Delhi-NCR and Uttar Pradesh & this will continue in the coming days and this will be increased also...Already the prices of tomatoes in the wholesale mandis in Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka have started coming down below Rs 100 and we expect this to help us. As of today, we have booked tomatoes through Kolar mandi - coming to Delhi at Rs 85/kg...We have also initiated imports from Nepal by removing the import restrictions and the first lot of tomatoes from Nepal are likely to reach Varanasi, Kanpur by Friday itself: FM
The BJP leader says the NCCF is planning a mega-sale of tomatoes in Delhi-NCR at a subsidised rate of Rs 70/kg this weekend, which will be covering all nooks and corners of Delhi.
Has DMK forgotten Jayalalithaa, you pulled her saree, asks Sitharaman in Lok Sabha
Nirmala Sitharaman has concluded her address to the Lok Sabha.
Rahul Gandhi reaches Parliament
Owaisi asks PM if 'Hindutva is more important than country'
AIMIM MP Asaduddin Owaisi says, "Our Home Minister was talking about 'Quit India' yesterday. I wonder if he gets to know that the word 'Quit India' was coined by a Muslim, he will not use this word. I want to say that the kind of politics you (Central govt) are doing will harm the country. I want to ask the PM if Hindutva is more important than the country."
Tharoor requests LS Speaker to reverse expunction of Rahul's address
Congress MP Shashi Tharoor says, "...They have deleted expressions like 'Murder of Bharat Mata' (from Congress MP Rahul Gandhi's speech) and so on which are not defamatory. The use of the word 'murder' is metaphorical. It is suggesting that by saying the 'Murder of Bharat Mata' it means that the idea of India is being annihilated...What is even more amusing is that the same speech was quoted by BJP speakers like Smriti Irani and it has not been expunged in their speech...We have requested the Speaker to reverse the expunction."
TMC MP Mahua Moitra addresses Lok Sabha on the no-confidence motion.
This is not has-no-confidence-in-govt motion, this is have-confidence-in-India motion, says Mahua Moitra.
Issue in Manipur is that of a hate crime, says Mahua Moitra.
Beg you to change the administrator in Manipur, says Moitra
TMC MP Mahua Moitra says, "We are here to ask the question in our 'tum abhi chup raho' republic where the PM tells a Governor 'chup raho'. We as elected MPs in this House are routinely told 'chup raho'. This motion is to break this code of silence in Manipur. PM Modi will not listen to us, he will come on the last day and give his speech. I don't know what is more unfortunate, our PM refuses to come to the Parliament or that he refuses to go to Manipur."
This no-confidence motion is to break this code of silence on Manipur, the most pressing issue of the day, where we are all supposed to 'raho chup' (keep silent). This is not just a no-confidence-in-government motion, this is a have-confidence-in-India motion :Mahua Moitra in Lok Sabha
"Six thousand five hundred FIRs in three months, which state has seen this? Four thousand houses destroyed, sixty thousand people displaced, which state has seen this?" says TMC MP Mahua Moitra during no-confidence motion debate in Lok Sabha.
Lok Sabha MP Congress leader Hibi Eden says, "Churachandpur is cut off from the rest of Manipur, 290 tribal villages have been burned in the state, this is a institutional attack on the minorities of this country, against Christians, Modi hai toh mumkin hai."
Meanwhile, ruckus and sloganeering has marred Rajya Sabha proceedings.
Rajya Sabha has been adjourned till tomorrow amid ruckus and sloganeering by the Opposition.
Pharmacy (Amendment) Bill, 2023 to amend the Pharmacy Act, 1948 passed in the Rajya Sabha. Earlier, the Bill was passed by the Lok Sabha on August 7.
Lok Sabha MP Chirag Paswan backs the government on the debate on the no-confidence motion moved by the opposition parties. In a scathing attack on JDU chief Nitish Kumar, Paswan says he (Nitish) has been rejected by the people.
Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury addresses Lok Sabha on the no-confidence motion debate.
"Bahumat ki Bahubali aapke paas hai, lekin humein kyun yeh no-confidence motion laana pade usko thoda samjane ki koshish karte hai," says Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury.
Why is PM so rigid, asks Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury.
Modi arrives in Lok Sabha amid Adhir Ranjan's address
PM Modi should keep his 'mann ki baat' on Manipur forward, says Adhir Ranjan in Lok Sabha.
Congress MP Adhir Ranjan says, "The power of no-confidence motion has brought the Prime Minister in the Parliament today. None of us were thinking about this no-confidence motion. We were only demanding that PM Modi should come to the Parliament and speak on the Manipur issue. We were not demanding any BJP member to come to the Parliament, we were only demanding our PM to come."
Uproar in Lok Sabha after Congress's Adhir Ranjan comments on PM Modi.
Congress MP Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury says, "Jab Dhritrashtra andhe the, tab Droupadi ka vastra haran hua tha, aaj bhi raja andhe baithe hai... Manipur aur Hastinapur mein koi farq nahi hai."
Anurag Thakur addresses Lok Sabha.
Oppn using Manipur for political gains: Anurag Thakur
Parliamentary Affairs Minister Pralhad Joshi demands expunction of Adhir Ranjan's remarks. "... Prime Minister is a high authority. This should be expunged and he should apologise."
BJP's Scindia attacked the Opposition saying that it was Amit Shah who paid visit to violence-hit Manipur, but none of the Opposition leaders went there.
The 'Seven Sisters' were the 'Seven neglected Sisters' during UPA regime, says Scindia.
"Now, we are the fifth largest economy. During the UPA's decades-long regime, India came up from 12th to 10th position only. But under NDA, India became fifth largest economy in last nine years": Scindia
"They (Congress) say they will bring 'mohabbat ki dukan'. But their dukan only has corruption and arrogance. Dukan ka naam badla hai, par samaan wohi hai," Scindia said.
By bringing a no-confidence motion against Modi govt, the opposition has shown 'overconfidence of stupidity', says BJP MP Rajyavardhan Singh Rathore
Rathore attacks the Opposition on alleged cases of rapes in Rajasthan.
"I was at the 2008 Beijing Olympics (in China). We came to know that Sonia and Rahul Gandhi are coming to meet us. They didn't come to meet us. They met the Communist Party of China. They should be tried for treason," says BJP's Rathore.
"Chhattisgarh has become ATM for Congress. Rapes, corruption and scams have become a common thing in the state," says BJP leader Vijay Baghel.
"The BJP has not done anything for the backward class. This is a capitalist govt which only helps the rich," says JD(U) in the LS.
AIUDF chief Badruddin Ajmal appealed politicians not to use religion for politics. He also charged that justice was served to only side in regard to the Haryana violence.
PM Modi arrived at the Lok Sabha to reply to the no-trust motion.
The Opposition's no-confidence motion has always proven to be lucky for us, Modi says.
"There have been many important bills that were discussed in the Parliament. But the opposition kept opposing all the bills, because they only understand politics now," says Modi.
"The opposition through their acts have proved that party is always bigger than the country for them."
"The best part of this match was that the fielding was set by the opposition, but all the fours & sixes were hit from our side," says Modi.
PM targets Congress asking why they did not give enough chance to Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury to speak in the House.
The PM recalls the earlier two Lok Sabha election results stressing that the people of the country have trust on the NDA.
"Some are trying to defame India, but the world has now seen the true picture of India."
"Today, India is seeing rapid rise of startups and exports. Today, the poor can dream of fulfilling their dreams."
The WHO has said that 4 lakh people's lives are being saved through Jal Jeevan mission, PM says.
"Distrust and arrogance have now got into their blood," Modi targets Oppn.
The Oppn's favourite slogan is 'Modi teri kabre khudegi', says Modi.
"They have a secret blessing. Whenever they want something bad to happen to someone, only good happens to that person. I am the best example to prove this point," says Modi.
"The Oppn spoke negatively about India's economy, HAL and LIC. All these three sectors have seen massive rise, again proving my point of them having a secret blessing," PM said.
"I had said earlier that India would become world's third largest economy in NDA's third term. As an Oppn, it should have asked the govt about the roadmap or could have given some suggestions to achieve it. But what they said is - 'It would anyway have happened'. I think this lethargic approach had kept India behind all these years"
The nation now believes that in 2028, when you would bring no-trust motion against us, India would have already become the third largest economy, says Modi.
Congress does not have trust on India, its people. But I must tell you, it is the people of India who have no confidence in Congress, says PM as the Opposition raised slogans on Manipur.
"The Opposition's problem is in order to keep themselves relevant, they had to take NDA's support. And in the process, they broke India as well into pieces - I.N.D.I.A"
"Congress has nothing in original. From its poll symbol to ideologies, everything is stolen."
"Everyone in I.N.D.I.A alliance wants to become PM."
Congress leader Sonia Gandhi and opposition members during the discussion on the Motion of No-Confidence in the Lok Sabha in the Monsoon session of Parliament, in New Delhi, Thursday, Aug. 10, 2023.
Credit: PTI Photo