Italian cheese takes on an Indian accent

Hundreds of Sikh immigrants have replaced natives who have little desire to work at dairies
Last Updated : 11 September 2011, 14:36 IST
Last Updated : 11 September 2011, 14:36 IST

Follow Us :


For the past 20 years, Indian immigrants from Punjab have been settling in Italy’s agricultural heartland to work primarily on farms, often as bergamini, as dairy workers are known in the native dialect.

It has been said that if the Indian workers went on strike, production of Grana Padano, the hard, grainy, spaghetti-topper that this tract of the Po Valley is known for, would shut down.

“Well, I don’t know if production would stop, but it would certainly create many difficulties,” said Simone Solfanelli, the president of the Cremona chapter of Coldiretti, Italy’s largest agricultural organisation. “I can tell you that they are indispensable for farming,” and for the milk produced in the province – at one million tonnes per year, about a tenth of all milk produced in Italy, he added.

The Indians, many of whom are Sikhs, first arrived in the area just as a generation of dairy workers was retiring, with no substitutes in sight. “They saved an economy that would have gone to the dogs because young people didn’t want to work with cows,” said Dalido Malaggi, the mayor of Pessina Cremonese. Though the dairy industry is mostly mechanised today, human labour is still necessary 365 days a year, he explained.

The work is split into two four-hour shifts per day, about 12 hours apart. “Young Italians don’t want to work those kinds of hours,” he said. “They’d prefer to work in factories and have evenings and weekends free.” It was a fortunate match, because many of the immigrants already knew what it took to keep a farm running.

“This is dairy land, and many of us have cows in Punjab,” said Jaswinder Duhra, who has lived in Italy for 25 years, working first as a bergamino and then for one of Italy’s best-known cheese manufacturers. “We’re used to the work that we do here.”

There are no official statistics of how many Indians work in dairy barns here, but Solfanelli said that of the 3,000 agricultural labourers in the province, about a third were Indian.

One measure of their presence was the inauguration last month of the Gurdwara Sri Guru Kalgidhar Sahib, a Sikh temple designed to hold 600 comfortably (though at least six times as many people attended the opening ceremony on Aug. 21). It has been touted as the largest Sikh temple in Continental Europe.

Built in an industrial area that includes a factory that makes vacuum pump compressors and a cold-cut production plant, the temple was inspired by Sikh models in India “but is both a monument and a centre for the community,” said its designer, Giorgio Mantovani. (Other Sikh temples in the vicinity are sited in repurposed poultry farms or warehouses.)

The road from the drawing board to the gleaming white structure that rises amid soya and corn fields was not without its rocky patches. Municipal permits were given in a nearby town and withdrawn when the temple became a politically thorny issue, so another site was found.

A decade’s worth of bureaucratic hurdles also had to be overcome, money had to be raised by the Sikh community, and loans found to make up the rest of the price tag of 2 million euros, or nearly $3 million. “It took years, but we all pitched in as best we could,” Duhra said.

The temple is still missing a fountain in front of the entrance and the gilded cupolas that characterise Sikh architecture. The latter have been a matter of some concern, because Cremona’s clammy, foggy winters “make gold a bad choice,” said Malaggi, the mayor. Various other construction materials are being considered.

Support and defiance
While the mayor was an active supporter of the temple, and the road sign into town proudly proclaims Pessina Cremonese to be “free from racial prejudices,” there was some opposition from local politicians with the Northern League, the political party most closely associated with anti-immigrant oratory in Italy. A small group of protesters from Forza Nuova, an extreme right party, demonstrated when the temple opened.

Manuel Gelmini, a Northern League lawmaker in Cremona’s provincial council who unsuccessfully tried to block the building of the temple, said his main concern was the Kirpan, the ceremonial sword carried by orthodox Sikhs. “For us, it’s a weapon, and people shouldn’t be allowed to go around armed,” he said.

He also objected to the use of Punjabi as the lingua franca in the temple. “They live in Lombardy,” he said. “How can there be integration if we allow them to speak their own language in a public space?”

But tellingly, the Northern League has not campaigned openly against the Indian immigrants working as bergamini. “As long as they respect our laws, work legally and learn Italian, they are welcome in our country,” Gelmini said.

Dilbagh Singh arrived in Italy when he was 14, and now, 12 years later, he speaks with the distinctive accent of his adopted hometown, Nogara, near Mantua. He said his compatriots “come here to work, and want to live peacefully.” To this end, Singh runs a Web site on Sikhs in Italy so that “Italians can understand us.” “We want people to know who we are,” he said.

Nearly 16,000 Indian immigrants are legally employed in agriculture in Italy, with the Latium region becoming the newest pole of immigration, especially for seasonal workers.

“You only have to travel 100 kilometers from Rome to discover a world most people don’t even know exists,” said Patrizia Santangeli, a filmmaker whose documentary about the Sikh community in the province of Latina, “Visit India,” is to have its premiere in October.
Santangeli’s documentary exposes some of the exploitation that many immigrant workers are subject to, regardless of their provenance.

“They often live in camps, like homeless people, and can get paid low wages, 2 euros to 4 euros an hour for 12-hour days,” she said. “But what struck me is that even though they live in difficult conditions, the Indian workers are still able to see the positive side of situations.”

In the north, life seems less harsh, at least on the surface. Many of the Indian immigrants have become Italian citizens. Many have bought homes and settled their families here.

According to the national statistics agency, about 40 per cent of all Indian immigrants to Italy are women, but only a small percentage have jobs. In the case of Pessina Cremonese, concerns about their isolation have been sporadically addressed with Italian lessons and work-training programs, and labour unions have offered similar programs in other towns.

Many of the Indian immigrants have also raised children in Italy, who imagine a different future. “They work hard at school; they’re not spoiled like our kids,” said Gianluigi Fiamenghi, who employs seven Indian workers on his dairy farm of 1,700 cows. “And their children won’t want to work on a farm. They’ll go to university and want to get ahead.”

One of Fiamenghi’s workers, Prem Singh, moved to Italy in 1995, and many of his relatives followed. He and his wife are raising three children now in primary school. “They feel more Italian than Indian,” Singh said, adding that he had no plans to return to his native land. “We’ve put down our roots here. It’s our home, and that’s that.”

Published 11 September 2011, 14:08 IST

Follow us on :

Follow Us