Pope Francis passes away: What AI chatbots said about his legacy

Pope Francis passed away on April 21, at the age of 88, after he had recovered from a serious bout of double pneumonia. As the world mourns the loss, here is what Artificial Intelligence had to say about his legacy.

Track live updates as the world mourns Pope Francis' demise

ChatGPT

A silhouette of Pope Francis

Reflecting on his legacy, Pope Francis is remembered as a transformative figure who sought to bring the Church closer to the marginalised and address pressing global issues. His papacy was marked by a commitment to social justice, environmental stewardship, and interfaith dialogue. He was known for his humility, often choosing simplicity over grandeur, and for his efforts to reform the Church's approach to modern challenges

Global leaders have paid tribute to his life and work. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi expressed being "deeply pained" by his passing, acknowledging the Pope's efforts in promoting peace and compassion . European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen highlighted his inspiration beyond the Catholic Church, noting his humility and love for the less fortunate .​

While his progressive stances garnered admiration, they also sparked debate within the Church. His critiques of capitalism and resistance to certain reforms, such as the ordination of women, were points of contention .​

Pope Francis's death marks the end of a significant era for the Catholic Church. His enduring legacy will continue to influence discussions on faith, justice, and compassion worldwide.​

Grok

The late Pope Francis pictured sitiing on a chair

Francis, born Jorge Mario Bergoglio in Buenos Aires, Argentina, was a historic figure: the first Jesuit pope, the first from the Americas, and the first non-European pope since the 8th-century Syrian Pope Gregory III. His papacy, which began on March 13, 2013, was marked by a focus on humility, inclusivity, and reform, often challenging the traditional structures of the Catholic Church. He sought to make the Church more accessible, famously calling for a "church for the poor" and emphasising outreach to marginalized communities, including the poor, migrants, and the LGBT+ community. His decision to live in the Vatican guesthouse, Casa Santa Marta, rather than the ornate papal apartments, and his use of a modest car instead of a limousine, underscored his commitment to simplicity and humility.

One of his most notable efforts was pushing for a more inclusive Church. He opened key roles to women, such as appointing an Italian nun as the first female governor of Vatican City in 2025, and made strides toward greater acceptance of LGBT+ individuals, including the controversial 2023 document Fiducia Supplicans, which allowed blessings for same-sex couples in non-liturgical settings. These moves, while celebrated by progressives, sparked significant backlash from conservative factions within the Church, who felt he was diluting sacred traditions. His reforms also extended to governance, with efforts to reorganize the Roman Curia and address financial misconduct, as seen in the 2023 conviction of Cardinal Angelo Becciu for fraud and embezzlement.

Francis was a vocal advocate on global issues like climate change, framing it as a moral imperative, and he championed interfaith dialogue, hosting a groundbreaking conference in February 2025 that brought together religious leaders worldwide. His criticism of policies like the Trump administration’s mass deportations—particularly his rebuke of US Vice President J D Vance’s use of the Catholic concept of ordo amoris to justify nativism—highlighted his willingness to confront political leaders on moral grounds. He also addressed the Church’s sexual abuse crisis, though his handling of cases like that of Father Marko Rupnik drew criticism for perceived leniency and lack of transparency.

However, his legacy is not without contradictions. While he pushed for progressive changes, some critics argue he didn’t go far enough—failing to fully resolve issues like priestly celibacy or the ordination of women, as seen in the unrealized outcomes of the 2018 Amazon Synod. Others, like Benedict XVI’s biographer Peter Seewald, have claimed Francis undermined his predecessor’s legacy, particularly through actions like restricting the Traditional Latin Mass, which reportedly caused Benedict personal distress. Additionally, his centralization of power, such as extending Cardinal Giovanni Battista Re’s term as dean of the College of Cardinals in February 2025 to influence the conclave, has been seen by some as a strategic move to protect his progressive vision, potentially at the expense of broader consensus.

Reflecting critically, Francis’s papacy seems to have been a balancing act between modernization and tradition, often leaving both sides unsatisfied. His emphasis on mercy and dialogue brought many back to the Church—sometimes called the “Pope Francis effect”—but it also deepened ideological divides, setting the stage for a potentially contentious succession. The fact that he appointed nearly three-quarters of the cardinals eligible to vote in the next conclave, many from the Global South, suggests his influence will linger, but whether his vision endures will depend on the Church’s next steps.

Posts on X today reflect a polarized sentiment: some praise his compassion and advocacy for peace, particularly his calls for a ceasefire in Gaza, while others see his death as an opportunity for the Church to shift direction, possibly toward a more conservative stance. His legacy, then, might be best understood as a bridge—imperfect, but pivotal—between the Church’s past and its uncertain future.

Meta AI

Pope Francis holds up a thumb

Pope Francis' legacy is marked by his progressive leadership and unwavering commitment to social justice, compassion, and reform within the Catholic Church. Here are some key aspects of his legacy.

- Advocacy for the Marginalized: He consistently championed the rights of the poor, the vulnerable, and the marginalized, emphasising the importance of caring for those in need.

- Environmental Responsibility: Pope Francis has been a vocal advocate for environmental protection, highlighting the need for sustainable practices and care for the planet.

- Interfaith Dialogue: He promoted unity and understanding among different faiths, fostering greater cooperation and mutual respect.

- Reform within the Church: Pope Francis implemented significant reforms, including increased transparency and accountability in governance and finances, and encouraged open dialogue on previously contentious topics.

- Synodality: He emphasized the importance of synodality, encouraging collaboration and discussion among bishops and other church leaders to address complex issues.

- Compassionate Leadership: Through his words and actions, Pope Francis demonstrated a commitment to compassion, humility, and mercy, inspiring millions worldwide.

Some notable achievements during his papacy include:

- Meeting with Patriarch Kirill: Pope Francis met with Russian Orthodox Patriarch Kirill, marking a significant step towards greater understanding between the Catholic and Orthodox churches.

- Document on Human Fraternity: He signed the Document on Human Fraternity with Sheikh Ahmed el-Tayeb, promoting peace, mutual respect, and coexistence among different faiths.

- Encyclicals: Pope Francis authored influential encyclicals, such as "Fratelli Tutti," which emphasizes global solidarity, social justice, and the common good.

Overall, Pope Francis' legacy is characterized by his tireless efforts to promote compassion, understanding, and reform within the Catholic Church and beyond.

Claude

Pope Francis looks on as he leaves Regina Coeli prison after a visit, in Rome

Pope Francis's papacy was truly transformative for the Catholic Church. Taking office in 2013 as the first Jesuit pope and the first from the Americas, he brought a distinctive pastoral approach that emphasized mercy, humility, and care for the marginalized.

What stands out most about his legacy was his focus on social justice, environmental stewardship, and a more inclusive church. His encyclical "Laudato Si'" established him as a significant voice on climate change, calling for an "ecological conversion" and connecting environmental degradation with poverty and global inequality.

Francis consistently advocated for migrants and refugees during the global migration crisis, making powerful symbolic gestures like visiting refugee camps and bringing refugee families to the Vatican. His efforts to reform Vatican finances and address the sexual abuse crisis, while sometimes criticized as insufficient, represented important steps toward accountability.

His openness to dialogue on previously rigid church positions regarding divorce, homosexuality, and other controversial issues signaled a shift toward greater pastoral flexibility without changing core doctrine. His attempts to decentralize church authority and empower local bishops' conferences reflected his vision of a "synodal" church.

What I find most remarkable was his authentic embodiment of the values he preached - living in simpler quarters than his predecessors, washing the feet of prisoners, and bringing a personal warmth to the papacy that resonated with many beyond the Catholic faith.

While his papacy had its critics from both progressive and traditional corners of Catholicism, Francis leaves behind a church that has been challenged to return to its roots of mercy and service to the poor.

Deepseek

Pope Francis leads the Pentecost Mass

Pope Francis, born Jorge Mario Bergoglio, has been a transformative figure in the Catholic Church, known for his humility, emphasis on mercy, and commitment to social justice. His legacy would likely be remembered for:

- Advocacy for the Poor and Marginalized – His focus on economic inequality, refugees, and the dignity of all people, encapsulated in teachings like Evangelii Gaudium and Fratelli Tutti.

- Progressive Stances with Controversial Pushback – While upholding traditional doctrine on issues like abortion and priestly celibacy, he shifted tone on LGBTQ+ inclusion, famously saying, "Who am I to judge?"

- Environmental Stewardship – Laudato Si’, his encyclical on climate change, framed environmental care as a moral imperative, influencing global discourse.

- Institutional Reform – Efforts to combat clerical abuse and financial corruption, though critics argue he could have gone further.

- Interfaith Dialogue & Global Diplomacy – Bridging divides, from Orthodox Christians to Muslims, and mediating conflicts like the U.S.-Cuba thaw.