Nothing to do with climate change: Conservative media, Donald Trump align views on fires

Rush Limbaugh told millions of his radio listeners to set aside any suggestion that climate change was the culprit for the frightening spate of wildfires ravaging California and the Pacific Northwest.

“Man-made global warming is not a scientific certainty; it cannot be proven, nor has it ever been,” Limbaugh declared on his Friday show, disregarding the mountains of empirical evidence to the contrary.

He then pivoted to a popular right-wing talking point: Policies meant to curtail climate change are, in fact, an assault on freedom.

“Environmentalist wackos” — Limbaugh’s phrase — “want man to be responsible for it because they want to control your behaviour,” the conservative host said on the show. He added that they “want to convince you that your lifestyle choices are the reason why all these fires are firing up out on the Left Coast.”

Hours later, that message leapt to prime time on Fox News, where host Tucker Carlson said those who blamed climate change for the fires were merely reciting “a partisan talking point.”

Read: Donald Trump dismisses climate concerns as he visits fire-ravaged western US

“In the hands of Democratic politicians, climate change is like systemic racism in the sky,” Carlson told viewers. “You can’t see it, but rest assured, it’s everywhere, and it’s deadly. And like systemic racism, it is your fault.”

Limbaugh and Carlson are two of the most prominent commentators in the right-wing media sphere, where a rich history of climate denialism has merged with Trump-era cultural warfare to generate a deep skepticism of the notion that climate change is a factor in the fires devastating the West Coast.

Like President Donald Trump, conservative media stars dismiss climate change — which scientists say is the primary cause of the conflagration — and point to the poor management of forestland by local (and, conveniently, Democratic) officials. Fringe right-wing websites, like The Gateway Pundit, have blamed left-wing arsonists, fueling false rumours that authorities say are impeding rescue efforts.

Visiting California on Monday to witness the destruction firsthand, Trump took Western states to task for failing to manage the forests properly and asserted, with no evidence, that the climate “will start getting cooler.”

“Just watch,” he added. “I don’t think science knows, actually.”

The president’s comments echoed his overly optimistic promises this year about the coronavirus — “it’s going to disappear,” Trump said in February — but were likely to resonate with fans of the conservative media personalities who routinely defend his agenda.

And Trump continues to play down environmental factors. Asked on Tuesday’s Fox & Friends about his policy plans for fighting climate change, the president replied: “You have forests all over the world. You don’t have fires like you do in California.”

Also Read: How this year's destructive US West wildfire season came to be

Californians have been debating how to reduce the risk of deadly blazes, with some officials arguing for more controlled burns. An August news release from the office of Gavin Newsom, the California governor, noted that the state’s forests were “highly vulnerable to catastrophic wildfire and in need of active, science-based management,” in part because of hotter and drier conditions created by climate change.

Newsom has called for the federal government to play a more active role in managing the state’s forests. About 58 per cent of California forestland is controlled by the federal government; the state owns 3 per cent.

For environmental advocacy groups, problematic media coverage of the wildfires is not limited to platforms associated with the right.

The Environmental Defense Fund, in a scathing post, said many mainstream news outlets had failed to draw a direct link between the widespread destruction and the dangerous consequences of a changing climate.

“It is like talking about the increased spread of Covid-19 while ignoring the reason it is spreading,” the group wrote.