The Taliban are only pretending they aren’t barbaric

Taliban's promises are discredited by events on the ground

By Eli Lake

The Taliban would like the world to know that they’re no longer the child-bride-marrying mass murderers that they used to be.

At a press conference Tuesday, Taliban spokesman Zabihullah Mujahed said there would be no reprisals against Afghans who worked with the US military. Women would be free to work and study, and the media free to broadcast what it wished, so long as both stayed “within our cultural frameworks.” How enlightened.

These promises are discredited by events on the ground. Those Afghans hanging from a US military jet taking off from Kabul clearly do not take the Taliban at their word. Nor do the women who Taliban gunmen escorted from their jobs at a Kandahar bank and ordered not to return. Nor do the journalists who work at a radio station in Kabul who saw their station manager murdered earlier this month by Taliban gunmen.

Read | Human remains found in landing gear of military flight from Kabul: US Air Force

But Mujahed is not trying to convince Afghans about the intentions of the Taliban. He is hoping his make-believe will persuade President Joe Biden and his administration to keep subsidising the Afghan government these jihadists just overthrew.

It’s easy to see why. Mujahed’s boss, Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar, the likely interim president of Afghanistan, managed to sucker US envoy Zalmay Khalilzad into thinking the Taliban were interested in a political settlement to share power. It’s now apparent that the Taliban used those negotiations as a political weapon to demoralize the Afghan military, with no intention of ever reaching an agreement. The plan worked surprisingly well, as the rapid collapse of the Afghan army attests.

So now the Taliban are hoping to fool America twice. Until this weekend, the Biden administration had committed to at least $300 million in reconstruction assistance after the US withdrawal to “demonstrate our enduring support for the Afghan people.” And the Afghan people certainly need it. According to a 2019 World Bank study, 75% of the Afghan government budget is funded by international donors, with the US the largest by far.

The good news is that the Biden administration has begun to set out conditions for recognising the Taliban. Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Sunday told CNN that the US would recognize and work with a Taliban emirate in Afghanistan if it respected the rights of its citizens and didn’t harbor terrorists. More promising is news that the Treasury Department has frozen all Afghan government assets in US banks.

Read | India will wait and watch before deciding on engaging with new regime in Afghanistan

But one never knows with the Biden administration. After all, it is still trying to negotiate the lifting of sanctions and return of frozen assets with another Islamic regime, in Iran, that shows as much respect for human rights — and as much hospitality to international terrorists — as the Taliban. When Afghanistan’s rapid collapse became apparent last week, Khalilzad dangled the prospect of US aid for a Taliban-led government if it spared the US embassy in its rout of Kabul.

Biden would be wise to reject proposals that try to leverage US assistance to reform the Taliban. They are irredeemable. It was bad enough that Biden abandoned Afghanistan despite the warnings of his military leaders. Worse still was how the administration failed to plan for the rescue of American civilians and Afghan allies before the military withdrawal. To subsidize the barbaric regime that has now taken over would be a final, ignominious blow to America’s honor.