India's trade policy lacks transparency: US

"The US continues to be concerned about the lack of transparency in many aspects of India's trade policy," Michael Punke, US Ambassador to World Trade Organization (WTO) said at the WTO Trade Policy Review (TPR) of India in Geneva on Wednesday, according to transcripts available here.

This contributes greatly to the difficulties of firms, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises, trying to invest in and trade with India, and helps explain India's ranking of 165 out of 183 countries in the World Bank's 2011 "Doing Business" report, he said.
"In addition to India's failure to submit required notifications to the WTO, particularly in the areas of agriculture, subsidies, SPS and TBT, India does not regularly issue draft regulations or engage in the timely public consultations that would ensure the development of sound policies in matters affecting trade and investment," he said.
Traders often face difficulties in areas like customs valuation, tariffs and other charges, internal taxation, import licensing, and trade remedies, because of opaque or inconsistently-applied procedures, Punke said, adding that a uniform, all-of government approach to the development of regulations would go a long way to addressing these concerns.

Noting that the lack of transparency in India's trade policy regime led the US to ask India so many written questions for this TPR, Punke said "the US became increasingly amazed at how many matters it found to be important and for which it was unable to obtain answers independently." Punke said the US encourages India to take advantage of the opportunities to implement meaningful economic reforms which will significantly advance India's objectives of inclusive growth and economic development, as it continues to grow dynamically and strengthen its trade policy institutions.

The US joins other WTO members in supporting India's use of an open trade policy to fulfilling these broader objectives, he said.

"Our support for such an approach, however, underscores our disappointment in India's reluctance to participate in meaningful market opening through the Doha Round negotiations, despite India's place as one of the world's fastest growing economies," he said.

Observing that the US recalls that transparency and predictability in a member's trade policy regime are critical for traders and investors, Punke said "in this respect, the US commends recent steps taken by the Indian government towards improving the transparency and effective functioning of its policymaking institutions.

"Last year's decision by the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion to begin issuing consolidated FDI policies has helped investors avoid searching through various press notes and clarifications in order to determine the extent to which sectors were open for investment," he said.

"In addition, the continuing implementation of the Right to Information Act, begun in 2005, has been invaluable in providing affected parties with the legally enforceable right to receive information about the government's operations," Punke said.