Pahalgam terror attack: Voices in Kashmir call for lawful confrontation of terrorism amid home demolitions

Srinagar: As authorities in Kashmir continue their crackdown on terror networks following the deadly attack in Pahalgam, voices within the Valley have begun calling for a more balanced approach — one that confronts terrorism within the limits of the law, ensuring that civilians are not unfairly punished.

The aftermath of the brutal Pahalgam terror attack, which claimed the lives of 26 civilians, mostly tourists, has sparked a widespread condemnation of the violence.

However, alongside the anger, concerns are rising over the methods employed by authorities in their efforts to root out terrorism.

In particular, the ongoing demolitions of homes linked to active terrorists and videos circulating on social media showing the destruction of houses have sparked outrage.

Mehbooba Mufti, former Chief Minister and opposition People’s Democratic Party (PDP) president, took to social media to express his concerns.

"The Government of India must tread with caution and carefully distinguish between terrorists and civilians following the recent Pahalgam attack. It must not alienate innocent people, especially those opposing terror.

"There are reports of thousands being arrested and scores of houses of common kashmiris being demolished along with those of militants. Appeal Government to direct the authorities to take care that innocent people are not made to feel the brunt as alienation aids terrorists goals of division and fear,” she posted on X.

Her sentiments were echoed by Mirwaiz Umar Farooq, Kashmir’s chief cleric and Hurriyat Conference chairman.

“While Kashmiri’s collectively condemn the heinous crime at Pahalgam, and it is imperative to bring its perpetrators to justice, indiscriminate arrests and videos circulating on social media of demolition of houses and neighbourhoods, is disturbing and distressing,” he posted on X. “I urge the authorities, that in seeking justice for the innocent victims, not to punish innocent Kashmiri families.”

These calls for a measured response were echoed by other prominent voices, including Tahir Sayeed, a former media analyst of Mehbooba Mufti.

Sayeed, too, expressed concern over collective punishment. “Accountability must be individual, not collective. Kashmiris have unequivocally condemned the Pahalgam attack, taking to the streets to make their stance clear. Yet, the demolition of homes and the imposition of collective punishment risk deepening alienation,” he wrote on X.

The demolition of properties linked to active terrorists, and the raids on neighborhoods suspected of harboring sympathizers, have raised fear that such actions, while aimed at dismantling terror networks, may inadvertently affect those who have no connection to terrorism, further exacerbating the sense of injustice felt by locals.

“Justice demands that the government confront terrorism firmly but within the bounds of law and uphold fairness for innocent civilians,” Sayeed added.

In a region that has seen decades of conflict, with civilians often caught in the crossfire between terror groups and security forces, these calls for a lawful and measured response resonate deeply with many in the Valley.

As the authorities continue their crackdown, the balance between security measures and respect for the rights of civilians will remain a delicate issue, one that requires careful consideration to avoid fueling further tensions.