2G: Essar, Loop move SC against trial before special CBI court

Essar and Loop group, charge sheeted along with its promotors, today today moved the Supreme Court challenging the criminal proceeding against it before the special CBI court in the 2G case.

They submitted before a bench headed by Justice G S Singhvi that the proceedings against them should be conducted before a Magistrate as the companies and their officials are not charged under Prevention of Corruption Act (PCA) like other accused in the multi-crore scam.

"I have a right to say that I be heard in the court of Magistrate as there is no charge against me under PCA," senior advocate Harish Salve, appearing for the Essar group, said.

The group approached the apex court after being asked by the Delhi High Court to seek a clarification whether the special court can conduct a trial of companies which are not charged under the PCA in the case arising out of the probe in the 2G spectrum scam case.

At the outset, the bench observed that its order for conducting the trial in the case was very clear.

"The High Court should have read the order. It is very clear," the bench said and objected to the appeal filed on the issue and asked the company to "avail" proper remedy available to it.

Salve then submitted that he would file an interim application and sought adjournment.

The court then listed the matter for hearing on February 17.
In the meantime, CBI, which had also filed an application for clarification on the issue, withrdew its plea.

The High Court had said that the apex court's directions, restraining any other judicial fora to entertain any plea in the matter, were coming in its way from hearing the petitions of telecom firms.

Besides Essar, the other accused named in the third chargesheet in the 2G case are telecom firm Loop Mobile India Ltd, Essar group promoters Anshuman and Ravi Ruia along with Loop Telecom promoters Kiran Khaitan, her husband I P Khaitan and Essar Group director (Strategy and Planning) Vikash Saraf.

The chargesheet has been filed under section 420 (cheating) and 120B (criminal conspiracy) of the IPC and the accusations against the firms are triable by a magistrate and not by the special court constituted under the PC Act for hearing the 2G case, Essar, in its petition, said.

Essar and Loop had moved the HC seeking a stay on the administrative order of the Registrar of the High Court which had ordered constitution of the special court.

Nilesh Doshi, whose recording of statement concluded today, said shares of Swan Capital (P) Ltd were purchased by Tiger Traders (P) Ltd, after which it came under the control of Parrot Consultants Services (P) Ltd and Zebra Consultants (P) and Tiger Traders (P) Ltd.

He said Reliance ADA Group Chairman Anil Ambani was not the Chairman of Tiger Traders (P) Ltd, Parrot Consultants Services (P) Ltd and Zebra Consultants (P).

He said Anand Bhatt, an independent solicitor having a firm named Wadia Ghandy and Company, had approached him in 2006 to create a structure of companies for his foray into telecom business.

"Anand Bhatt informed me that less than 10 per cent shares of the proposed telecom company would be held by Reliance Telecom Ltd and the remaining would be held by telecom fund headed by Ashok Wadhwa and Anand Bhatt," he said.