SC refuses to stay NGT order on opening Sterlite plant

The Supreme Court on Tuesday refused to stay the National Green Tribunal's (NGT) order of December 15 to re-open the Sterlite copper plant at Thoothukudi.

A bench presided over by Justice R F Nariman, however, stayed the December 21 Madurai bench order of the Madras High Court which had ordered status quo in the matter.

The top court issued a notice to Vedanta Ltd on a special leave petition filed by the Tamil Nadu government.

“The directions that have been passed by the National Green Tribunal, by its judgment dated 15.12.2018, will continue to subsist and will be subject to the ultimate outcome of the appeal,” the bench also comprising Justice Navin Sinha, said.

In its petition, the state government claimed that the tribunal failed to consider the entire gamut of data, documents and evidence in the case to show that the plant had “irreversibly polluted the groundwater in and around the district”.

The tribunal chose to direct the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board (TNPCB) to pass fresh orders of renewal of consent and issue an authorisation to Vedanta Limited to handle hazardous substances, it said.

“There are no reasons but mere conclusions in the impugned order (of NGT). It is unfortunate that the NGT has not bestowed adequate and serious consideration of the environmental pollution caused by the respondent’s unit,” the state government claimed.

It also claimed that the tribunal could not have appointed a committee headed by former high court chief justice Tarun Aggarwala to prepare a report in the case.

The NGT relied upon the committee's report which had failed to consider any of the contentions as well as documents, it further contended.

“The NGT assumed a non-existent jurisdiction but having done so, failed to exercise it by considering the facts and evidence while arriving at findings,” the state government claimed.

Notably, the apex court had last month refused to stay a Madras High Court order for a CBI probe against police and district officials for firing at anti-Sterlite protesters in Tamil Nadu on May 22 and 23 last year, claiming 13 lives and leaving scores others injured.