Actor Naseeruddin Shah recently appeared on ‘Be a man, Yaar!’- a talk show hosted by Nikhil Taneja. While at the show, Shah commented on unhealthy traits of masculinity and stereotypes attached with traditional gender roles. One particular part of the interview, wherein Shah addressed Taneja’s question on whether men, feeling emotionally drained, tend to enjoy illogical masala movies purely for entertainment, has come under the radar of social media.
“Women’s lives, particularly housewives’ lives are tougher and that is why a film which women like, will always be a success. And women like sensitive things. But men have this luxury of indulging..Bohot thaka hua hoon, jaao, paani lao, din bhar kaam kiya hai”. Arre! do women sleep a full day? They are also working, and probably more than you. So it's purely an indulgence and nothing else. I really admire those who help at home, those who understand their responsibilities that they too live in the house and therefore help in performing chores..The men, they say ‘I came by bus, I’m tired’…Arre Mard ho, thak kaise gye!” Shah had said.
This segment has sparked considerable debate on gender roles within households. The sarcasm behind ‘mard ho, thak kaise gye’ (you’re a man, why are you tired) seems to have missed the pole, with people also pointing out to ‘insensitivity’ towards men that Shah’s statement elicit.
Here are some of the comments on Shah's statement :
"Mard ho to thak kyun Gaye" where is his sensitivity. One thing people need to understand is portraying human emotions on screen doesn't necessarily mean the person actually understands and cares about it or feels it too, a portrayal is far from reality.
— Saroj (@sorose4u) September 29, 2023
Asking a "film institute" actor or filmmaker their opinion on masala movies is the Indian version of asking Scorsese his opinion on Marvel movies. The only difference is Scorsese is no hypocrite and makes valid points. Also, a lot of women enjoy films like KGF, Kantara, or RRR.
— Sajin Shrijith (@SajinShrijith) September 30, 2023
Some also agreed to his views, saying “Division of labor, understandable. Husband is working outside& earning, wife is working at home cooking, cleaning, etc But giving order to wife ‘bring tea,water, keep my stuff in place bring/take plate’ etc is demeaning. Everybody should do his/her work, contribute at domestic work.”
Dear Ms Arnaz Hathiram,
— عالم (@farazzaalam) September 29, 2023
Just because you fight for men's rights, you don't need to criticize everyone just for the sake of it. What Naseeruddin Shah has said holds true. It's not his problem if you don't understand his words or haven't watched this episode.
So, kindly shut up! https://t.co/WyAmNSs6yO
A film that women like will always be a successful film because women like sensitivity. The overdose of hypermasculine male characters in the film industry is a common tactic for guaranteed commercial success. We are not over this, are we? https://t.co/msQLBuVc3M pic.twitter.com/sieaaLvF1l
— Nakshatra (@ghalibkakhayal) September 28, 2023
Deccan Herald is on WhatsApp Channels| Join now for Breaking News & Editor's Picks