Stadium at Shimla's Annandale opposed

Commercial forces may exploit the hills, say residents

As the Himachal Pradesh government and the Indian Army fight it out over controlling Shimla’s historical Annandale ground, many residents are dead set against the state’s move to set up a multipurpose stadium in the area.

Criticising the Bharatiya Janata Party  government, the residents say taking Annandale away from the army's protective cover would expose it to commercial forces out to
exploit the beauty of the hills.

The residents rather apprehend that Annandale, in possession of the army since World War II, would be destroyed the way Mount Jakhu was - with concrete structures at the highest peak in the town located at an altitude of 8,500 feet.

“It’s the only surviving green lung of the town," said Capt (retd) Ved Sud, a third generation Shimla resident.

“The civil administration will rape the pristine beauty of Annandale and surrounding hills coated with oaks and deodars. The government’s plan would destroy something that is of historical and ecological value,” said Sud, who is also convener of the Shimla chapter of the Indian National Trust for Art and Cultural Heritage (Intach).

At a meeting of chief ministers on internal security in New Delhi, Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister Prem Kumar Dhumal on Monday took up his government’s row with the army over possession of Annandale ground.

The 121-bigha flat highland ringed by dense groves (one bigha is 0.4 hectare), just three kilometres from Shimla's Ridge, has been a flashpoint of confrontation between the state and the army as the latter does not allow the ground for civilian use.

Dhumal said the ground is in the illegal possession of the defence authorities as its lease had expired many years back.

Various sports organisations and local residents under the banner of Himachal Pradesh Cricket Association (HPCA), headed by Anurag Thakur, who is BJP member of parliament and son of Dhumal, on April 7 took out a public rally in Shimla, seeking the ground’s transfer to the local administration.

Disaster in making

But Rajesh Mehta, former director of the state’s town and country planning department and a resident, said: “At no cost would Annandale be handed over to the state. The manner in which it gobbled up the forest in Dharamsala by constructing a cricket stadium, it will be another disaster in the making.”

Peeping into Annandale's glorious past, Raja Bhasin, a Shimla-based writer-cum-historian, said it was once used by Durand Football Tournament Society instituted in 1888.

Author E J Buck wrote in his book ‘Simla Past and Present’ that Major Kennedy, a British officer, was so struck with the ground’s beauty that he named it after Anna, a young woman he was in love with back home. Dale, or a meadow, was tagged on to her name to make the ground Annandale.

Protests

“We have organised protest marches at Annandale to counter the army's claims that the ground is of national strategic importance. We want to bring to the notice of the people that these mock drills and mobilisation of machinery have started after our campaign was launched. Why was there no activity before that?” asked Ashwani Garg, president of Annandale for Citizens.

Countering the claims of some that the army is using it only to play golf, Brig A K  Sharma of the army's Western Command said that the ground is strategically and logistically important for the army to carry out exercises and operations in forward areas.

Sharma said the armed forces were regularly conducting exercises, both operational and disaster management, in addition to routine training.

M R Kaundal, retired government employee who settled in Shimla in 1945, said till the early 1990s, civilians were allowed to play cricket, hockey and football matches at Annandale.